arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2303.04229cs.AIcs.CL
收藏

理解自然语言理解系统。的批判性分析

Understanding Natural Language Understanding Systems. A Critical Analysis

Alessandro Lenci

摘要:

开发“像我们一样说话”的机器,也被称为自然语言理解(NLU)系统,是人工智能(AI)的圣杯,因为语言是人类智能的精髓。NLU在人工智能和自然语言处理(NLP)领域的研究短暂而激烈,充满了起起落落,人们对圣杯最终触手可及寄予厚望,通常随后是同样深刻的绝望和幻灭阶段。但是,我们可以构建“会说话的机器”的信任从来没有比上一代NLU系统所产生的信任更强大。但是,在人工智能中闪闪发光的是金子吗?最先进的系统是否拥有与人类语言知识相当的东西?我们是否正处于一个新时代的黎明,圣杯终于离我们更近了?事实上,人工智能系统的最新成就已经引发了,或者更好地说,重新引发了关于其真正语言理解能力的激烈科学辩论。有些人认为,尽管计算模型仍然显示出局限性,但我们确实走在了正确的道路上。另一些人则持根本怀疑态度,甚至不屑一顾:目前的限制不仅仅是NLU系统的偶然性和暂时性问题,而是基于它们的认识论和技术范式的内在不足的标志。本文旨在通过对最新的自然语言理解系统的语言能力进行批判性分析,为这种辩论做出贡献。我认为,它们包含了人类学习和处理语言的重要方面,但同时它们缺乏关键的解释和推理技能,除非它们与结构化知识相结合,并能够利用它来使用语言,否则它们不太可能获得这些技能。

英文摘要:

The development of machines that «talk like us», also known as Natural Language Understanding (NLU) systems, is the Holy Grail of Artificial Intelligence (AI), since language is the quintessence of human intelligence. The brief but intense life of NLU research in AI and Natural Language Processing (NLP) is full of ups and downs, with periods of high hopes that the Grail is finally within reach, typically followed by phases of equally deep despair and disillusion. But never has the trust that we can build «talking machines» been stronger than the one engendered by the last generation of NLU systems. But is it gold all that glitters in AI? do state-of-the-art systems possess something comparable to the human knowledge of language? Are we at the dawn of a new era, in which the Grail is finally closer to us? In fact, the latest achievements of AI systems have sparkled, or better renewed, an intense scientific debate on their true language understanding capabilities. Some defend the idea that, yes, we are on the right track, despite the limits that computational models still show. Others are instead radically skeptic and even dismissal: The present limits are not just contingent and temporary problems of NLU systems, but the sign of the intrinsic inadequacy of the epistemological and technological paradigm grounding them. This paper aims at contributing to such debate by carrying out a critical analysis of the linguistic abilities of the most recent NLU systems. I contend that they incorporate important aspects of the way language is learnt and processed by humans, but at the same time they lack key interpretive and inferential skills that it is unlikely they can attain unless they are integrated with structured knowledge and the ability to exploit it for language use.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑