arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2207.08155physics.soc-phcond-mat.stat-mech
收藏

将选举结果与民意调查之间的系统性差异公之于众

Rationalizing systematic discrepancies between election outcomes and opinion polls

Luca Gamberi, Pierpaolo Vivo, Yanik-Pascal Förster, Evan Tzanis, Alessia Annibale

摘要:

布拉德利效应是指当候选人没有表现出意识形态、性别或种族的主流特征时,民意调查与实际选举结果之间的差异。这种效应在1982年加州州长选举中首次观察到,尽管黑人民主党候选人汤姆·布拉德利在民意调查中领先,但他还是输了。有人认为,民意调查的受访者可能倾向于掩盖他们真正的政治倾向,而倾向于社会普遍认为更能接受的政治倾向。我们提出了一个完全可解的统计力学模型,它允许定量探索这种现象。该模型包括三个主要成分:(i)个人倾向于将自己的真实偏好与其他人宣布的(公开)意见相一致,(ii)一个说明个人诚信因素的术语,该术语促使选民在其公开和私人意见之间保持一致,以及(iii)自我监督成分,它调节个体受社会规范影响并希望公开遵守社会规范的力量。我们观察到出现的秩序在广泛的参数范围内的模型,并讨论了噪声的影响隐藏和公众偏好之间的相关性。最后,我们提出了一个应用该模型的预测选举结果。

英文摘要:

The Bradley effect concerns the discrepancy between opinion polls and actual election outcomes that emerges when candidates do not exhibit ideological, sexual or racial mainstream features. This effect was first observed during the 1982 election for the Governor of California that resulted in a significant loss for the black Democratic candidate, Tom Bradley, despite him being ahead in polls. It has been argued that poll respondents may tend to mask their true political preference in favour of what is generally considered more socially acceptable. We propose an exactly solvable statistical mechanical model, which allows for a quantitative exploration of this phenomenon. The model includes three main ingredients: (i) the tendency of individuals to align their real preference to the declared (public) opinions of others, (ii) a term accounting for an individual integrity factor, which induces voters to be consistent between their public and private opinions, and (iii) a self-monitoring component, which tunes the strength by which an individual is affected by and wishes to publicly conform to social norms. We observe the emergence of order in a wide range of parameters of the model and discuss the effect of noise on the correlation between hidden and public preference. Finally, we present an application of this model to the prediction of election outcomes.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑