This note is an invited discussion of the article "Confidence Intervals for Nonparametric Empirical Bayes Analysis" by Ignatiadis and Wager. In this discussion, I review some goals of empirical Bayes data analysis and the contribution of Ignatiadis and Wager. Differences between across-group inference and group-specific inference are discussed. Standard empirical Bayes interval procedures focus on controlling the across-group average coverage rate. However, if group-specific inferences are of primary interest, confidence intervals with group-specific coverage control may be preferable.
Upper bounds on the minimum coverage probability of model averaged tail area confidence intervals in regression
频率主义模型平均已被提出作为将“模型不确定性”纳入置信区间构造的方法。环境和生态统计界对这些建议特别感兴趣。Turek和Fletcher在2012年提出的模型平均尾面积（MATA）置信区间是一种很有前途的方法。此区间的性能在很大程度上取决于它所基于的基于数据的模型权重。Kabaila，Welsh and Abeysekera，2016在两个嵌套线性回归模型的简单场景中提供了该区间覆盖概率的计算方便公式。我们考虑更复杂的情况，即有许多（在所考虑的示例中为32，768个）线性回归模型，如下所示。对于回归参数向量的一组指定分量中的每一个，我们要么将分量设置为零，要么让它自由变化。我们提供了一个易于计算的上限上的最小覆盖概率的MATA置信区间。该上限提供了反对使用基于贝叶斯信息准则（BIC）的模型权重的证据。
We congratulate the authors on their exciting paper, which introduces a novel idea for assessing the estimation bias in causal estimates. Doubly robust estimators are now part of the standard set of tools in causal inference, but a typical analysis stops with an estimate and a confidence interval. The authors give an approach for a unique type of model-checking that allows the user to check whether the bias is sufficiently small with respect to the standard error, which is generally required for confidence intervals to be reliable.
In an empirical Bayes analysis, we use data from repeated sampling to imitate inferences made by an oracle Bayesian with extensive knowledge of the data-generating distribution. Existing results provide a comprehensive characterization of when and why empirical Bayes point estimates accurately recover oracle Bayes behavior. In this paper, we develop flexible and practical confidence intervals that provide asymptotic frequentist coverage of empirical Bayes estimands, such as the posterior mean or the local false sign rate. The coverage statements hold even when the estimands are only partially …
In the analysis of survey data it is of interest to estimate and quantify uncertainty about means or totals for each of several non-overlapping subpopulations, or areas. When the sample size for a given area is small, standard confidence intervals based on data only from that area can be unacceptably wide. In order to reduce interval width, practitioners often utilize multilevel models in order to borrow information across areas, resulting in intervals centered around shrinkage estimators. However, such intervals only have the nominal coverage rate on average across areas under the assumed mod…
We consider the problem of interval estimation of the odds ratio. An asymptotic confidence interval is widely applied in medical research. Unfortunately that confidence interval has a poor coverage probability: it is significantly smaller than the nominal confidence level. In this paper a new confidence interval is proposed. The construction needs only information on sample sizes and sample odds ratio. The coverage probability of the proposed confidence interval is at least the nominal confidence level.
This is the rejoinder to the discussion by Kennedy, Balakrishnan and Wasserman on the paper "On nearly assumption-free tests of nominal confidence interval coverage for causal parameters estimated by machine learning" published in Statistical Science.
We consider interval estimation of the difference between two binomial proportions. Several methods of constructing such an interval are known. Unfortunately those confidence intervals have poor coverage probability: it is significantly smaller than the nominal confidence level. In this paper a new confidence interval is proposed. The construction needs only information on sample sizes and sample difference between proportions. The coverage probability of the proposed confidence interval is at least the nominal confidence level. The new confidence interval is illustrated by a medical example.
We introduce a new framework for creating point-wise confidence intervals for the distribution of event times for current status data. Existing methods are based on asymptotics. Our framework is based on binomial properties and motivates confidence intervals that are very simple to apply and are valid, i.e., guarantee nominal coverage. Although these confidence intervals are necessarily conservative for small sample sizes, asymptotically their coverage rate approaches the nominal one. This binomial framework also motivates approximately valid confidence intervals, and simulations show that the…
Bootstrap smoothed (bagged) parameter estimators have been proposed as an improvement on estimators found after preliminary data-based model selection. The key result of Efron (2014) is a very convenient and widely applicable formula for a delta method approximation to the standard deviation of the bootstrap smoothed estimator. This approximation provides an easily computed guide to the accuracy of this estimator. In addition, Efron (2014) proposed a confidence interval centered on the bootstrap smoothed estimator, with width proportional to the estimate of this approximation to the standard d…
Efficient conformal prediction intervals for time series: Online PID-Expert aggregation
School of Economics and Management, Beihang University（北京航空航天大学经济管理学院）；Beijing Shuji Intelligent Technology Co., Ltd.（北京数智科技有限公司）；Center for Forecasting Science, Academy of Mathematics and Systems Science, Chinese Academy of Sciences（中国科学院数学与系统科学研究院预测科学中心）
We propose several prediction intervals procedures for the individual treatment effect with either finite-sample or asymptotic coverage guarantee in a non-parametric regression setting, where non-linear regression functions, heteroskedasticity and non-Gaussianity are allowed. The construct the prediction intervals we use the conformal method of Vovk et al. (2005). In extensive simulations, we compare the coverage probability and interval length of our prediction interval procedures. We demonstrate that complex learning algorithms, such as neural networks, can lead to narrower prediction interv…
Empirical Bayes small area estimation based on the well-known Fay-Herriot model may produce unreliable estimates when outlying areas exist. Existing robust methods against outliers or model misspecification are generally inefficient when the assumed distribution is plausible. This paper proposes a simple modification of the standard empirical Bayes methods with adaptively balancing robustness and efficiency. The proposed method employs gamma-divergence instead of the marginal log-likelihood and optimizes a tuning parameter controlling robustness by pursuing the efficiency of empirical Bayes co…
In many statistical problems, several estimators are usually available for interval estimation of a parameter of interest, and hence, the selection of an appropriate estimator is important. The criterion for a good estimator is to have a high coverage probability close to the nominal level and a shorter interval length. However, these two concepts are in opposition to each other: high and low coverages are associated with longer and shorter interval lengths respectively. Some methods, such as bootstrap calibration, modify the nominal level to improve the coverage and thereby allow the selectio…
We present several related methods for creating confidence intervals to assess disease prevalence in variety of survey sampling settings. These include simple random samples with imperfect tests, weighted sampling with perfect tests, and weighted sampling with imperfect tests, with the first two settings considered special cases of the third. Our methods use survey results and measurements of test sensitivity and specificity to construct melded confidence intervals. We demonstrate that our methods appear to guarantee coverage in simulated settings, while competing methods are shown to achieve …
In this article, we derive and compare methods to derive \textit{p}-values and sets of confidence intervals with strong control of the family-wise error rates and coverage for estimates of treatment effects in cluster randomised trials with multiple outcomes. There are few methods for \textit{p}-value corrections and deriving confidence intervals, limiting their application in this setting. We discuss the methods of Bonferroni, Holm, and Romano \& Wolf (2005) and adapt them to cluster randomised trial inference using permutation-based methods with different test statistics. We develop a novel …
This paper introduces the jackknife+, which is a novel method for constructing predictive confidence intervals. Whereas the jackknife outputs an interval centered at the predicted response of a test point, with the width of the interval determined by the quantiles of leave-one-out residuals, the jackknife+ also uses the leave-one-out predictions at the test point to account for the variability in the fitted regression function. Assuming exchangeable training samples, we prove that this crucial modification permits rigorous coverage guarantees regardless of the distribution of the data points, …
There are over 55 different ways to construct a confidence respectively credible interval (CI) for the binomial proportion. Methods to compare them are necessary to decide which should be used in practice. The interval score has been suggested to compare prediction intervals. This score is a proper scoring rule that combines the coverage as a measure of calibration and the width as a measure of sharpness. We evaluate eleven CIs for the binomial proportion based on the expected interval score and propose a summary measure which can take into account different weighting of the underlying true pr…
This article illustrates how indirect or prior information can be optimally used to construct a prediction region that maintains a target frequentist coverage rate. If the indirect information is accurate, the volume of the prediction region is lower on average than that of other regions with the same coverage rate. Even if the indirect information is inaccurate, the resulting region still maintains the target coverage rate. Such a prediction region can be constructed for models that have a complete sufficient statistic, which includes many widely-used parametric and nonparametric models. Part…
The estimation of coverage probabilities, and in particular of the missing mass, is a classical statistical problem with applications in numerous scientific fields. In this paper, we study this problem in relation to randomized data compression, or sketching. This is a novel but practically relevant perspective, and it refers to situations in which coverage probabilities must be estimated based on a compressed and imperfect summary, or sketch, of the true data, because neither the full data nor the empirical frequencies of distinct symbols can be observed directly. Our contribution is a Bayesi…
The asymptotic behaviour of the commonly used bootstrap percentile confidence interval is investigated when the parameters are subject to linear inequality constraints. We concentrate on the important one- and two-sample problems with data generated from general parametric distributions in the natural exponential family. The focus of this paper is on quantifying the coverage probabilities of the parametric bootstrap percentile confidence intervals, in particular their limiting behaviour near boundaries. We propose a local asymptotic framework to study this subtle coverage behaviour. Under this…
It can be argued that optimal prediction should take into account all available data. Therefore, to evaluate a prediction interval's performance one should employ conditional coverage probability, conditioning on all available observations. Focusing on a linear model, we derive the asymptotic distribution of the difference between the conditional coverage probability of a nominal prediction interval and the conditional coverage probability of a prediction interval obtained via a residual-based bootstrap. Applying this result, we show that a prediction interval generated by the residual-based b…
We construct robust empirical Bayes confidence intervals (EBCIs) in a normal means problem. The intervals are centered at the usual linear empirical Bayes estimator, but use a critical value accounting for shrinkage. Parametric EBCIs that assume a normal distribution for the means (Morris, 1983b) may substantially undercover when this assumption is violated. In contrast, our EBCIs control coverage regardless of the means distribution, while remaining close in length to the parametric EBCIs when the means are indeed Gaussian. If the means are treated as fixed, our EBCIs have an average coverage…
Impact of existence and nonexistence of pivot on the coverage of empirical best linear prediction intervals for small areas
Department of Mathematics & Statistics, Eastern Kentucky University（东肯塔基大学数学与统计系）；Institute of Mathematics for Industry, Kyushu University（九州大学产业数学研究所）；Joint Program in Survey Methodology, University of Maryland（马里兰大学联合调查方法项目）
This paper studies higher-order inference properties of nonparametric local polynomial regression methods under random sampling. We prove Edgeworth expansions for $t$ statistics and coverage error expansions for interval estimators that (i) hold uniformly in the data generating process, (ii) allow for the uniform kernel, and (iii) cover estimation of derivatives of the regression function. The terms of the higher-order expansions, and their associated rates as a function of the sample size and bandwidth sequence, depend on the smoothness of the population regression function, the smoothness ex…
CONTINA: Confidence Interval for Traffic Demand Prediction with Coverage Guarantee
Key Laboratory of Road and Traffic Engineering, Ministry of Education at Tongji University（同济大学交通工程教育重点实验室）；Urban Mobility Institute, Tongji University（同济大学城市交通研究院）
