Physical limitations on broadband invisibility based on fast-light media
Mohamed Ismail Abdelrahman, Zeki Hayran, Aobo Chen, Francesco Monticone
备注：
- A Comment on "Ultrabroadband 3D invisibility with fast-light cloaks" by Tsakmakidis, et al. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-12813-2 - A Reply to 'Reply to 'Physical limitations on broadband invisibility based on fast-light media' '
This note is a comment on a recent article [Tsakmakidis, et al., Nat Commun 10 (2019)] that presents a thought-provoking proposal to overcome the bandwidth restrictions of invisibility cloaks based on using media that support superluminal (faster than light in free space) group and phase velocities. As illustrated in Fig. 1 of the original article, a wave packet propagating through such a fast-light cloak is alleged to be able to reach the side behind the cloaked object simultaneously with a corresponding wave packet propagating through the shorter, direct route in free space without the object, so that "no shadow or waveform distortion arises." As the authors claim, the "extra pathlength is balanced out by the correspondingly larger group velocity of the pulse in the cloak", which allows to "restore the incident field distribution all around the object in, both, amplitude and phase". This fast-light effect may be achieved in a broadband fashion using active (gain) materials. The authors claim that such a fast-light cloak can hide an object, even from time-of-flight detection techniques, and achieve invisibility "over any desired frequency band." We disagree with these claims and believe that a thorough clarification of the ideas put forward in the original article is important and necessary for the broad wave-physics community. Specifically, in this comment we clarify that invisibility cloaks based on fast-light media suffer from fundamental bandwidth restrictions that arise due to causality, the nature of superluminal wave propagation, and the stability issues of active systems. These limitations and issues were not addressed in [Tsakmakidis, et al., Nat Commun 10 (2019)]. Most importantly, we show that the material model considered in the original article is unphysical.
Inspired by the magnificent features of two-dimensional (2D) materials which aroused much of the interest in recent materials science research, we study PT-symmetric 2D Weyl semimetal (WSM) to reveal the broadband and wide-angle invisible configurations in a PT-symmetric optical slab system. Desired unidirectional reflectionlessness and invisibility phenomena is obtained by the optimal control of system parameters. We unravel the mystery of broadband and wide-angle invisibility in regular slab materials with finite refractive indices by means of the plenary expressions. We show that materials …
Achieving exact unidirectional invisibility in a finite frequency band has been an outstanding problem for many years. We offer a simple solution to this problem in two dimensions that is based on our solution to another more basic open problem of scattering theory, namely finding scattering potentials $v(x,y)$ in two dimensions whose scattering problem is exactly solvable for energies not exceeding a critical value $E_c$. This extends the notion of quasi-exact solvability to scattering theory and yields a simple condition under which the first Born approximation gives the exact expression for…
A flexible control of wave scattering in complex media is of relevance in different areas of classical and quantum physics. Recently, a great interest has been devoted to scattering engineering in non-Hermitian systems, with the prediction and demonstration of new classes of non-Hermitian potentials with unique scattering properties, such as transparent and invisibile potentials or one-way reflectionless potentials. Such potentials have been found for both continuous and discrete (lattice) systems. However, wave scattering in lattice systems displays some distinct features arising from the dis…
Replacement of ensemble averaging by the use of a broadband source in scattering of light from a one-dimensional randomly rough interface between two dielectric media
Dielectric photonics platform provides unique possibilities to control light scattering via utilizing high-index dielectric nanoantennas with peculiar optical signatures. Despite the intensively growing field of all-dielectric nanophotonics, it is still unclear how surrounding media affect scattering properties of a nanoantenna with complex multipole response. Here we report on light scattering by a silicon cubic nanoparticles embedded in lossless media, supporting optical resonant response. We show that significant changes in the scattering process are governed by the electro-magnetic multipo…
Implementation of ultra-broadband optical null media via space-folding
Key Lab of Advanced Transducers and Intelligent Control System, Ministry of Education and Shanxi Province, College of Physics and Optoelectronics, Taiyuan University of Technology（先进换能器与智能控制系统教育部及山西省重点实验室，物理与光电学院，太原理工大学）
Fundamentals and Applications of Time-varying Media: A Review
Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics（南京航空航天大学）；Southeast University（东南大学）；Nanyang Technological University（南洋理工大学）；Shanghai Radio Equipment Research Institute（上海无线电设备研究所）
Plasmonic enhancement of nonlinear light-matter interaction can be achieved via dedicated optimization of resonant plasmonic modes that are spectrally matched to the different wavelengths involved in the particular nonlinear optical process. In this work, we investigate the generation and enhancement of broadband four-wave mixing (FWM) in a plasmonic azimuthally chirped grating (ACG). The azimuthally varying grating periodicity in an ACG offers a well-defined channel to mediate the near field and the far field over a broad range of wavelengths. However, the particular mechanism responsible for…
