Extensive frequency response and inertia analysis under high renewable energy source integration scenarios: application to the European interconnected power system
Ana Fernández-Guillamón, Emilio Gómez-Lázaro, Angel Molina-García
Traditionally, power system's inertia has been estimated according to the rotating masses directly connected to the grid. However, a new generation mix scenario is currently identified, where conventional supply-side is gradually replaced by renewable sources decoupled from the grid by electronic converters (i.e., wind and photovoltaic power plants). Due to the significant penetration of such renewable generation units, the conventional grid inertia is decreasing, subsequently affecting both reliability analysis and grid stability. As a result, concepts such as 'synthetic inertia', 'hidden inertia' or 'virtual inertia', together with alternative spinning reserves, are currently under discussion to ensure power system stability and reliability. Under this new framework, an algorithm to estimate the minimum inertia needed to fulfil the ENTSO-E requirements for ROCOF values is proposed and assessed under a relevant variety of imbalanced conditions. The additional active power needed to be within the frequency dynamic range is also estimated and determined. Both inertia and additional active power can come from different sources, such as storage solutions, renewable sources decoupled from the grid including some frequency control strategies, interconnections with other grids, or a combination of them. The power system under consideration includes thermal, hydro-power plants, and renewable generation units, in line with most current and future European supply-side power systems. More than 700 generation mix scenarios are identified and simulated, varying the renewable integration, the power imbalance, and the inertia constant of conventional power plants. In fact, the solutions studied here provide important information to ease the massive integration of renewable resources, without reducing the capacity of the grid in terms of stability and response to contingencies.
This paper proposed an approach to identify the change of inertia distribution in high renewable power systems. Using the footprints of electromechanical wave propagation at the distribution level, this approach provides a new and non-invasive way to aware the system inertia distribution for primary frequency response. Actual measurements and high renewable dynamic models validated effectiveness of the approach.
Traditionally, inertia in power systems has been determined by considering all the rotating masses directly connected to the grid. During the last decade, the integration of renewable energy sources, mainly photovoltaic installations and wind power plants, has led to a significant dynamic characteristic change in power systems. This change is mainly due to the fact that most renewables have power electronics at the grid interface. The overall impact on stability and reliability analysis of power systems is very significant. The power systems become more dynamic and require a new set of strateg…
The progressive integration of electronic converter based Renewable Energy Sources will lead to a reduction of the system synchronous inertia that can endanger the system frequency stability behavior, especially in the case of isolated or poorly interconnected systems, such as the case of Iberian Peninsula system. This work focuses on the study of the impact that the synchronous inertia reduction can have on the Iberian system frequency stability for different critical operation scenarios and disturbances. For this purpose, an equivalent dynamic model of the Iberian system interconnected with …
Load-generation balance and system inertia are essential for maintaining frequency in power systems. Power grids are equipped with Rate-of-Change-of Frequency (ROCOF) and Load Shedding (LS) relays in order to keep load-generation balance. With the increasing penetration of renewables, the inertia of the power grids is declining, which results in a faster drop in system frequency in case of load-generation imbalance. In this context, we analyze the feasibility of launching False Data Injection (FDI) in order to create False Relay Operations (FRO), which we refer to as FRO attack, in the power s…
In small/medium-sized isolated power networks with low rotational inertia and high penetration of renewables, generation/load contingency events may cause large frequency excursions, potentially leading to cascading failures and even blackouts. Therefore, it is crucial for system operators to be able to monitor the state of the network in real-time and predict the maximum possible frequency deviations at all times. This paper presents a real-time frequency stability (RTFS) tool developed by the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) and operationalized in the control room for the South West …
Insufficient flexibility in system operation caused by traditional "heat-set" operating modes of combined heat and power (CHP) units in winter heating periods is a key issue that limits renewable energy consumption. In order to reduce the curtailment of renewable energy resources through improving the operational flexibility, a novel optimal scheduling model based on chance-constrained programming (CCP), aiming at minimizing the lowest generation cost, is proposed for a small-scale integrated energy system (IES) with CHP units, thermal power units, renewable generations and representative auxi…
To stabilize the frequency of the renewable energy sources (RESs) dominated power system, frequency supports are required by RESs through virtual inertia emulation or droop control in the newly published grid codes. Since the long-term RES prediction involves significant errors, we need online configure the frequency control parameters of RESs in a rolling manner to improve the operation economics under the premise of stabilizing system frequency. To address this concern, this paper proposes a frequency constrained stochastic look-ahead power dispatch (FCS-LAPD) model to formulate the frequenc…
On the path towards power systems with high renewable penetrations and ultimately carbon-neutral, more and more synchronous generation is being displaced by variable renewable generation that does not currently provide system inertia nor reactive power support. This could create serious issues of power system stability in the near future, and countries with high renewable penetrations such as Ireland are already facing these challenges. Therefore, this paper aims at answering the questions of whether and how explicitly including inertia and reactive power constraints in generation expansion pl…
Modern electricity grids throughout the world, particularly in islands such as Great Britain, face a major problem on the road to decarbonisation: the significantly reduced level of system inertia due to integration of Renewable Energy Sources (RES). Given that most RES such as wind and solar are decoupled from the grid through power electronics converters, they do not naturally contribute to system inertia. However, RES could support grid stability through appropriately controlling the converters, but currently no market incentives exist for RES to provide this support. In this paper we devel…
Maintaining the stability of renewable-dominant power systems requires the procurement of virtual inertia services from non-synchronous resources (e.g., batteries, wind turbines) in addition to inertia traditionally provided by synchronous resources (e.g., thermal generators). However, the pricing of inertia provision has not been studied in a stochastic electricity market, where the uncertainty characteristics of renewable energy sources (RES) are considered. To fill in this research gap, this paper formulates a chance-constrained stochastic unit commitment model with inertia requirements and…
Conventional synchronous machines are gradually replaced by converter-based renewable resources. As a result, synchronous inertia, an important time-varying quantity, has substantially more impact on modern power systems stability. The increasing integration of renewable energy resources imports different dynamics into traditional power systems; therefore, the estimation of system inertia using mathematical model becomes more difficult. In this paper, we propose a novel learning-assisted inertia estimation model based on long-term recurrent convolutional network (LRCN) that uses system wide fr…
Nowadays, power system inertia is changing as a consequence of replacing conventional units by renewable energy sources, mainly wind and PV power plants. This fact affects significantly the grid frequency response under power imbalances. As a result, new frequency control strategies for renewable plants are being developed to emulate the behaviour of conventional power plants under such contingencies. These approaches are usually called 'virtual inertia emulation techniques'. In this paper, an analysis of power system inertia estimation from frequency excursions is carried out by considering d…
The infusion of renewable energy sources into the conventional synchronous generation system decreases the overall system inertia and negatively impacts the stability of its primary frequency response. The lowered inertia is due to the absence of inertia in some of the renewable energy-based systems. To maintain the stability of the system, we need to keep the frequency in the permissible limits and maintain low rotational inertia. Some authors in the literature have used the virtual synchronous generators (VSG) as a solution to this problem. Although the VSG based distributed recourses (DER) …
Integration of intermittent renewable energy sources in modern power systems is increasing very fast. Replacement of synchronous generators with zero-to-low variable renewables substantially decreases the system inertia. In a large system, inertia distribution may vary significantly, areas of low inertia are more susceptible to frequency deviation, posing risks of load shedding and generation trip. Therefore, it is necessary for operators to evaluate and quantify the system inertia and its distribution in real time. This paper proposes a novel synchronized phasor measurement units (PMUs)-based…
The synchronized operation of power generators is the foundation of electric power network stability and a key to the prevention of undesired power outages and blackouts. Here, we derive the conditions that guarantee synchronization in power networks with inherent generator heterogeneity when subjected to small perturbations, and perform a parametric sensitivity analysis to understand synchronization with varied types of generators. As inverter-based resources, which are the primary interfacing technology for many renewable sources of energy, have supplanted synchronous generators in ever grow…
To ensure adequate and economic reserve for primary frequency response in the current and future power system, this paper proposes real-time frequency response reserve (FRR) requirement based on system inertia. This minimum FRR will help power system operators adjust the current frequency response requirement and accommodate more renewable generations while achieving a saving of both energy and facility costs. Most importantly, the ability to adaptively vary the FRR will provide the additional agility, resiliency, and reliability to the grid.
Tie-line power exchanges among regional power systems facilitate renewable accommodations. Power exchanges can be calculated via a tie-line security region that provides the feasible region of the coupling parameters among regional power systems. However, a tie-line security region is a high-dimension polytope due to multiple time periods and border buses inherently in power system operations, leading to the considerable computational burden. A fast calculation method for tie-line security regions in high dimension is studied in this paper. The high-dimension polytope across all the time perio…
Integration of renewable energy resources with the electric grid is necessary for a sustainable energy future. However, increased penetration of inverter based resources (IBRs) reduce grid inertia, which might then compromise power system reliability. Therefore, power utilities are often interested in identifying the maximum IBR penetration limit for their system. The proposed research presents a methodology to identify the IBR penetration threshold beyond which voltage, frequency, and tie-line limits will be exceeded. The sensitivity of the IBR penetration threshold to momentary cessation due…
Nowadays, power imbalance happens more frequently due to the more integration of renewable energy sources. Energy storage is a kind of devices that can charge energy at one time and discharge energy at another time. This function makes that storage is widely envolved into promoting power balance of power system. Besides this function, storage can also emulate virtual inertia to respond to frequency deviations in the system. This work provides a generalized optimization framework to analyze how to control power and virtual inertia from storage to participate in frequency response when a large d…
In order to improve dynamic characteristics of the power system with high-proportion renewable energy sources (RESs), it is necessary for the voltage source converter (VSC), interfaces of RESs, to provide inertial and frequency regulation. In practical applications, VSCs are better to be controlled as a current source due to its weak overcurrent capacity. According to the characteristic, a dual synchronous theory is proposed to analyze the synchronization between current sources in this paper. Based on dual synchronous idea, a dual synchronous generator (DSG) control is applied in VSC to form …
The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted our society by forcing shutdowns and shifting the way people interacted worldwide. In relation to the impacts on the electric grid, it created a significant decrease in energy demands across the globe. Recent studies have shown that the low demand conditions caused by COVID-19 lockdowns combined with large renewable generation have resulted in extremely low-inertia grid conditions. In this work, we examine how an attacker could exploit these {scenarios} to cause unsafe grid operating conditions by executing load-altering attacks (LAAs) targeted at compromisin…
As renewable resources gradually replace conventional generation based synchronous machines, the dynamics of the modern grid changes significantly and the system synchronous inertia decreases substantially. This transformation poses severe challenges for power system stability; for instance, it may lead to larger initial rate of change of frequency and increase frequency excursions. However, new opportunities also arise as novelconverter control techniques, so-called grid-forming strategies, show higher efficiency and faster response than conventional synchronous generators. They mainly involv…
The utilization of renewable energy sources (RESs) has become significant throughout the world especially over the last two decades. Although high-level RESs penetration reduces negative environmental impact compared to conventional fossil fuel based energy generation, control issues become more complex as well as total inertia to the system is significantly decreased due to removal of conventional synchronous generators. Some other technical issues, high uncertainties, low fault ride through capability, high fault current, low generation reserve, and low power quality, arise due to RESs integ…
Energy and water systems are highly interconnected. Energy is required to extract, transmit, and treat water and wastewater, and water is needed for cooling energy systems. There is a rapid increase in demand for energy and water due to factors such as population and economic growth. In less than 30 years, the need for energy and water will nearly double globally. As the energy and water resources are limited, it is critical to have a sustainable energy-water nexus framework to meet these growing demands. Renewable energies provide substantial opportunities in energy-water nexuses by boosting …
Modern power systems with high share of renewable generation are at the risk of rapid changes in frequency and inertia resulting from contingencies. The importance of an accurate assessment of system and load relief, as well as frequency changes in the critical timescales is more pronounced in these power systems. This knowledge serves as an insight which will guide the solutions required for enhanced security and resilience. A novel procedure for simultaneously assessing system inertia and load relief using a closed-form system frequency response (SFR) model to fit measured disturbance data i…
With the increasing penetration of converter-based renewable resources, different types of dynamics have been introduced to the power system. Due to the complexity and high order of the modern power system, mathematical model-based inertia estimation method becomes more difficult. This paper proposes two novel machine learning assisted inertia estimation methods based on long-recurrent convolutional neural (LRCN) network and graph convolutional neural (GCN) network respectively. Informative features are extracted from ambient measurements collected through phasor measurement units (PMU). Spati…
Increasing the inertia is widely considered to be the solution to resolving unstable interactions between coupled oscillators. In power grids, Virtual Synchronous Generators (VSGs) are proposed to compensate the reducing inertia as rotating synchronous generators are being phased out. Yet, modeling how VSGs and rotating generators simultaneously contribute energy and inertia, we surprisingly find that instabilities of a small-signal nature could arise despite fairly high system inertia. Importantly, we show there exist both an optimal and a maximum number of such VSGs that can be safely suppor…
Keeping the power system stable is becoming more challenging with the growing share of renewable energy sources of low or negligible inertia. Inertia constants for individual power plants are generally not known and are roughly estimated by considering the type of power generation technology and the nameplate capacity of plants. More accurate knowledge of inertia constants of individual power plants would give greater transparency to decisions of the transmission system operator (TSO) and to auctions for the procurement of inertia services. Additionally, a more accurate forecast or estimation …
A community integrated energy system (CIES) is an important carrier of the energy internet and smart city in geographical and functional terms. Its emergence provides a new solution to the problems of energy utilization and environmental pollution. To coordinate the integrated demand response and uncertainty of renewable energy generation (RGs), a data-driven two-stage distributionally robust optimization (DRO) model is constructed. A comprehensive norm consisting of the 1-norm and infinity-norm is used as the uncertainty probability distribution information set, thereby avoiding complex proba…
An increasing penetration of renewable generation has led to reduced levels of rotational inertia and damping in the system. The consequences are higher vulnerability to disturbances and deterioration of the dynamic response of the system. To overcome these challenges, novel converter control schemes that provide virtual inertia and damping have been introduced, which raises the question of optimal distribution of such devices throughout the network. This paper presents a framework for performance-based allocation of virtual inertia and damping to the converter-interfaced generators in a low-i…
Most renewable energy sources (RES) do not provide any inertial response. Their integration in a power grid implies a highly reduced level of system inertia, which leads to a deteriorated frequency performance. Then, the requirement for frequency response is significantly increased in order to maintain frequency security. Alternatively, enhanced provision of inertia from auxiliary sources may alleviate this problem. However, the benefits of inertia provision are not yet fully understood. In this paper, an inertia-dependent Stochastic Unit Commitment (SUC) tool is applied to quantify the econom…
The emerging paradigm of interconnected microgrids advocates energy trading or sharing among multiple microgrids. It helps make full use of the temporal availability of energy and diversity in operational costs when meeting various energy loads. However, energy trading might not completely absorb excess renewable energy. A multi-energy management framework including fuel cell vehicles, energy storage, combined heat and power system, and renewable energy is proposed, and the characteristics and scheduling arrangements of fuel cell vehicles are considered to further improve the local absorption …
Declines in cost and concerns about the environmental impact of traditional generation have boosted the penetration of renewables and non-conventional distributed energy resources into the power grid. The intermittent availability of these resources causes the inertia of the power system to vary over time. As a result, there is a need to go beyond traditional controllers designed to regulate frequency under the assumption of invariant dynamics. This paper presents a learning-based framework for the design of stable controllers based on imitating datasets obtained from linear-quadratic regulato…
The electric grid is undergoing a major transition from fossil fuel-based power generation to renewable energy sources, typically interfaced to the grid via power electronics. The future power systems are thus expected to face increased control complexity and challenges pertaining to frequency stability due to lower levels of inertia and damping. As a result, the frequency control and development of novel ancillary services is becoming imperative. This paper proposes a data-driven control scheme, based on Reinforcement Learning (RL), for grid-forming Voltage Source Converters (VSCs), with the …
Power grids are evolving toward 100% renewable energy interfaced by inverters. Virtual inertia and damping provided by inverters are essential to synchronism and frequency stability of future power grids. This paper numerically addresses the problem of dispatch of virtual inertia and damping (DID) among inverters in the transmission network. The DID problem is first formulated as a nonlinear program (NLP) by the Radua collocation method which is flexible to handle various types of disturbances and bounds constraints. Since the NLP of DID is highly non-convex, semi-definite programming (SDP) re…
A rapid deployment of renewable generation has led to significant reduction in the rotational system inertia and damping, thus making frequency control in power systems more challenging. This paper proposes a novel control scheme based on Model Predictive Control (MPC) for converter-interfaced generators operating in a grid-forming mode, with the goal of exploiting their fast response capabilities to provide fast frequency control service to the system. The controller manipulates converter power injections to limit the frequency nadir and rate-of-change-of-frequency after a disturbance. Both c…
