arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1904.10001astro-ph.HE
收藏

对"白矮星模拟中爆轰的数值稳定性"一文的评论

Comments on "Numerical Stability of Detonations in White Dwarf Simulations"

Doron Kushnir, Boaz Katz

摘要:

Katz & Zingale(2019,KZ19)最近研究了一个一维测试问题,旨在模拟两个碳-氧(CO)白矮星正面碰撞中的爆炸点火过程。除非人为提高温度或加入5%的He,否则它们在纯CO组合物中不能获得爆震点火。在这两种情况下,他们获得收敛点火的空间分辨率优于0.1公里,这是超出了多维模拟的能力。这与Kushnir等人(2013,K13)的主张相矛盾,即在几km的分辨率下实现了向$\sim10\%$的收敛。使用欧拉和拉格朗日代码,我们表明,在这个测试问题中,不需要他或增加温度的情况下,得到一个收敛和解决的点火纯CO。这两个代码同意在1%以内,并在几公里的分辨率收敛。我们计算的情况下,包括他和获得类似的缓慢收敛,但发现这是由于边界的数值伪影,可以(应该)避免。校正边界条件允许收敛,与K13的权利要求一致的$\sim10\,\textrm{km}$的分辨率。在这种情况下,KZ19获得的缓慢收敛可能是由于类似的边界数值伪影,但我们无法验证这一点。KZ19进一步建议避免使用K13引入的燃烧限制器。我们证明他们的建议是不合理的。

英文摘要:

Katz & Zingale (2019, KZ19) recently studied a one-dimensional test problem, intended to mimic the process of detonation ignition in head-on collisions of two carbon--oxygen (CO) white dwarfs. They do not obtain ignition of a detonation in pure CO compositions unless the temperature is artificially increased or 5% He is included. In both of these cases they obtain converged ignition only for spatial resolutions better than 0.1 km, which are beyond the capability of multidimensional simulations. This is in a contradiction with the claims of Kushnir et al. (2013, K13), that a convergence to $\sim10\%$ is achieved for a resolution of a few km. Using Eulerian and Lagrangian codes we show that a converged and resolved ignition is obtained for pure CO in this test problem without the need for He or increasing the temperature. The two codes agree to within 1% and convergence is obtained at resolutions of several km. We calculate the case that includes He and obtain a similar slow convergence, but find that it is due to a boundary numerical artifact that can (and should) be avoided. Correcting the boundary conditions allows convergence with resolution of $\sim10\,\textrm{km}$ in an agreement with the claims of K13. It is likely that the slow convergence obtained by KZ19 in this case is because of a similar boundary numerical artifact, but we are unable to verify this. KZ19 further recommended to avoid the use of the burning limiter introduced by K13. We show that their recommendation is not justified.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑