arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1807.10540cond-mat.mtrl-sci
收藏

对“锂离子电池负极用Li-Sn和Li-Sb金属间化合物的结构预测”一文的评论

Comment on "Structure Prediction of Li-Sn and Li-Sb Intermetallics for Lithium-Ion Batteries Anodes''

Raja Sen, Priya Johari

摘要:

在最近发表的一篇文章Mayo et al. [Chemistry of Materials 2017,29,5787]使用从头算随机结构搜索方法(AIRSS),从无机晶体结构数据库(ICSD)中进行高通量筛选,在环境压力(~0 GPa)和0 K温度下呈现了各种实验未知的Li-Sn金属间化合物的基态晶体结构。在他们的研究中,除了实验已知的Li-Sn相,例如$\mathrm{Li_{2}Sn_{5}}$($\mathrm{P4/mbm}$)、$\mathrm{Li_{1}Sn_{1}}$($\mathrm{P2/m}$、$\mathrm{I4_{1}/amd}$)、$\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{3}}$(PDMATHAMT)、$\mathrm{Li_{5}Sn_{2}}$($\mathrm{R\bar{3}m}$)、$\mathrm{Li_{13}Sn_{5}}$($\mathrm{P\bar{3}m1}$)、$\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{2}}$($\mathrm{Cmmm}$)和$\mathrm{Li_{17}Sn_{4}}$($\mathrm{F\bar{4}3m}$),Mayo等人还报道了Li-Sn的两个先前未知的稳定相,例如,$\mathrm{Li_{8}Sn_{3}}$ - $\mathrm{R\bar{3}m}$和$\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{2}}$ - $\mathrm{P\bar{1}}$以及几种Li-Sn亚稳相($\mathrm{Li_{1}Sn_{2}}$,$\mathrm{Li_{2}Sn_{3}}$,$\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{9}}$,$\mathrm{Li_{3}Sn_{2}}$,$\mathrm{Li_{5}Sn_{3}}$,$\mathrm{Li_{2}Sn}_{1}$,$\mathrm{Li_{3}Sn_{1}}$,$\mathrm{Li_{4}Sn_{1}}$,$\mathrm{Li_{5}Sn_{1}}$,和$\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{1}}$),其距离凸壳连接线在20 meV/原子范围内。然而,在阅读他们的文章时,我们注意到他们的结果存在显著的不一致和矛盾。此外,与我们发表的结果\cite{Sen@2017}进行一对一的比较,发现Mayo等人讨论的$\mathrm{Li_{3}Sn_{1}}$、$\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{2}}$、$\mathrm{Li_{4}Sn_{1}}$、$\mathrm{Li_{5}Sn_{1}}$和$\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{1}}$的对称性不一致。

英文摘要:

In a recently published article Mayo et al.[Chemistry of Materials 2017, 29, 5787] presented the ground state crystal structures of various experimentally unknown Li-Sn intermetallic compounds at ambient pressure (~0 GPa) and 0 K temperature using ab-initio random structure searching method (AIRSS) with high-throughput screening from the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database (ICSD).\cite{AIRSS} In their study, besides the experimentally known phases of Li-Sn such as, $\mathrm{Li_{2}Sn_{5}}$ ($\mathrm{P4/mbm}$),$\mathrm{Li_{1}Sn_{1}}$ ($\mathrm{P2/m}$, $\mathrm{I4_{1}/amd}$), $\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{3}}$ ($\mathrm{P2_{1}/m}$), $\mathrm{Li_{5}Sn_{2}}$ ($\mathrm{R\bar{3}m}$), $\mathrm{Li_{13}Sn_{5}}$ ($\mathrm{P\bar{3}m1}$), $\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{2}}$ ($\mathrm{Cmmm}$), and $\mathrm{Li_{17}Sn_{4}}$ ($\mathrm{F\bar{4}3m}$), Mayo et al. also reported two previously unknown stable phases for Li-Sn such as, $\mathrm{Li_{8}Sn_{3}}$-$\mathrm{R\bar{3}m}$ and $\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{2}}$-$\mathrm{P\bar{1}}$ along with several Li-Sn metastable phases ($\mathrm{Li_{1}Sn_{2}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{2}Sn_{3}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{9}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{3}Sn_{2}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{5}Sn_{3}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{2}Sn}_{1}$, $\mathrm{Li_{3}Sn_{1}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{4}Sn_{1}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{5}Sn_{1}}$, and $\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{1}}$) which lie within 20 meV/atom from the convex hull tie-line. However, while going through their article, we noticed a significant inconsistency and contradictions in their results. Moreover, a one-to-one comparison with our published results\cite{Sen@2017} revealed a disagreement in the symmetry of $\mathrm{Li_{3}Sn_{1}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{2}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{4}Sn_{1}}$, $\mathrm{Li_{5}Sn_{1}}$, and $\mathrm{Li_{7}Sn_{1}}$ discussed by Mayo et al.}

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑