In our digital and connected societies, the development of social networks, online shopping, and reputation systems raises the question of how individuals use social information, and how it affects their decisions. We report experiments performed in France and Japan, in which subjects could update their estimates after having received information from other subjects. We measure and model the impact of this social information at individual and collective scales. We observe and justify that when individuals have little prior knowledge about a quantity, the distribution of the logarithm of their estimates is close to a Cauchy distribution. We find that social influence helps the group improve its properly defined collective accuracy. We quantify the improvement of the group estimation when additional controlled and reliable information is provided, unbeknownst to the subjects. We show that subjects' sensitivity to social influence permits to define five robust behavioral traits and increases with the difference between personal and group estimates. We then use our data to build and calibrate a model of collective estimation, to analyze the impact on the group performance of the quantity and quality of information received by individuals. The model quantitatively reproduces the distributions of estimates and the improvement of collective performance and accuracy observed in our experiments. Finally, our model predicts that providing a moderate amount of incorrect information to individuals can counterbalance the human cognitive bias to systematically underestimate quantities, and thereby improve collective performance.
Wisdom of the Confident: Using Social Interactions to Eliminate the Bias in Wisdom of the Crowds
与个体相比,人类群体可以通过简单地使用个体估计的平均值、中位数或几何平均值来进行非常准确的估计[Galton 1907,Surowiecki 2005,第2008页]。然而,这只对某些任务是正确的,一般来说,这些集体估计显示出强烈的偏见。当考虑到社会互动时,该方法也失败了,这使得集体估计变得更糟,因为个体倾向于收敛到有偏差的结果[Lorenz等人,2011]。在这里,我们展示了社会互动对集体智慧的明显负面影响的光明面。我们发现,有些人抵制社会的影响,当使用这个小组的中位数,我们可以消除偏见的智慧的整个人群。为了找到这个对私人估计比对社会影响更有信心的个体亚组,我们将个体建模为将私人和社会信息与不同的相对权重相结合的估计量[Perez-Escudero & de Polavieja 2011,Arganda et al. 2012]。然后,我们通过排除那些在估计中使用较高社会影响力权重值的群体,计算了越来越小的群体的几何平均值。在这个过程中得到的趋势给出了无偏的结果,与计算整个组的中位数的简单方法相反。我们的研究结果表明,虽然一个简单的操作,如平均值,中位数或几何平均值的一组可能不允许群体作出良好的估计,一个更复杂的操作,考虑到个性的社会动态可以导致更好的集体智慧。