Given a set of $p$ players we consider problems concerning envy-free allocation of collections of $k$ pieces from a given set of goods or chores. We show that if $p\le n$ and each player can choose $k$ pieces out of $n$ pieces of a cake, then there exist a division of the cake and an allocation of the pieces where at least $\frac{p}{2(k^2-k+1)}$ players get their desired $k$ pieces each. We further show that if $p\le k(n-1)+1$ and each player can choose $k$ pieces, one from each of $k$ cakes that are divided into $n$ pieces each, then there exist a division of the cakes and allocation of the pieces where at least $\frac{p}{2k(k-1)}$ players get their desired $k$ pieces. Finally we prove that if $p\ge k(n-1)+1$ and each player can choose one shift in each of $k$ days that are partitioned into $n$ shifts each, then, given that the salaries of the players are fixed, there exist $n(1+\ln k)$ players covering all the shifts, and moreover, if $k=2$ then $n$ players suffice. Our proofs combine topological methods and theorems of Füredi, Lovász and Gallai from hypergraph theory.
An analysis of a fair division protocol for drawing legislative districts
Landau,Reid和Yershov [A Fair Division Solution to the Problem of Redistricting,\textit{Social Choice and Welfare},2008]提出了一种基于两个玩家公平划分过程来绘制立法选区的协议,其中每个玩家都有权为州的一部分绘制选区。我们称之为\textit{LRY protocol}。Landau和Su [Fair Division and Redistricting,arXiv:1402.0862,2014]提出了一种衡量州的地区公平性的方法,称为\textit{geometric target}。在本文中,我们证明了在LRY协议下,一方可以赢得的地区的数量最多可以比他们的几何目标少两个,假设没有几何约束的地区,并提供例子来证明这个界是紧的。我们还表明,如果LRY协议被应用在一个状态与几何约束,结果可以是任意远离几何目标。
CNRS, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, INSA Lyon, LIRIS(法国国家科学研究中心、里昂第一大学、里昂高等师范学院);McGill University(麦吉尔大学);Massachusetts Institute of Technology(麻省理工学院)