This paper presents a coordinate free pre-metric formulation of charge free Maxwell-Minkowski electrodynamics, and of the developed by the authors non-linear Extended Electrodynamics. First we introduce some formal relations from multilinear algebra and differential geometry to be used further. Then we recall and appropriately modify the existing pre-metric formulation of linear charge free electrodynamics in pre-relativistic and relativistic forms as preparation to turn to corresponding pre-metric nonlinearization. After some preliminary examples and notes on nonlinearization, we motivate our view for existence and explicit formulation of time stable subsystems of the physical field objects considered. Section 5 presents the formal results of our approach on the pre-metric nonlinear formulations in static case, in time-dependent case, and in space-time formulation. In the Conclusion we give our general view on "why and how to nonlinearize". The Appendix gives a possible formal extension of our aproach to many subsystem field objects.
Reply to Itin, Obukhov and Hehl paper "An Electric Charge has no Screw Sense - A Comment on the Twist-Free Formulation of Electrodynamics by da Rocha & Rodrigues"
An electric charge has no screw sense--a comment on the twistfree formulation of electrodynamics by da Rocha & Rodrigues
Da Rocha和Rodigues(RR)声称:(i)在经典电动力学中,矢量演算中对极矢量和轴矢量的区分,以及外部演算中对扭转和非扭转形式的区分是不适当的和多余的;(ii)他们可以从麦克斯韦方程组导出洛伦兹力方程。对于(i),我们指出,极性/轴向和扭转/非扭转的区别来自于电荷是纯标量的性质,即不携带任何螺旋感。因此,上述区别是电动力学任何基本理论的必要组成部分。如果将允许的坐标变换限制为具有正雅可比行列式的坐标变换(或规定一个等价的约束),则RR方案可以被容纳;然而,这样的限制是非法的,因为电动力学实际上在具有负雅可比行列式的变换下也是协变的。关于(ii)从麦克斯韦方程组“推导”洛伦兹力,我们指出RR首先忘记了给麦克斯韦方程组中的符号F(场强)一个运算意义。他们的证据是空的。总结:RR的方法并没有给电动力学的结构带来任何新的见解。