arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1602.09123cs.DLcs.SIphysics.soc-ph
收藏

论文撤稿对学术影响力影响的多维度考察

A Multi-dimensional Investigation of the Effects of Publication Retraction on Scholarly Impact

Xin Shuai, Isabelle Moulinier, Jason Rollins, Tonya Custis, Frank Schilder, Mathilda Edmunds

摘要:

在过去的几十年里,学术界的出版物撤回率急剧上升。在这项研究中,我们从定量的角度研究撤回,旨在回答两个基本问题。第一,撤回如何影响被撤回论文、作者和机构的学术影响?第二,这种影响力是否通过学术协会传播到更广泛的学术界?具体来说,我们分析了汤森路透科学网(WoS)中索引的一组撤回文章,并进行了多个实验,以比较学术影响力的变化与非撤回文章,作者和机构的对照组。我们进一步应用格兰杰因果关系检验来研究不同的科学主题是否受到这些主题内发生的撤回论文的动态影响。我们的研究结果显示了两个关键发现:第一,被撤回论文和作者的学术影响在撤回后显著下降,最严重的影响下降与基于已证实的有目的的科学不端行为的撤回有关;第二,这种撤回惩罚似乎不会通过更广泛的学术社交图谱传播,而是具有有限和局部的影响。我们的研究结果可以为学者或科学委员会提供有用的见解,以评估与撤回相关的论文,作者或机构的学术价值。

英文摘要:

Over the past few decades, the rate of publication retractions has increased dramatically in academia. In this study, we investigate retractions from a quantitative perspective, aiming to answer two fundamental questions. One, how do retractions influence the scholarly impact of retracted papers, authors, and institutions? Two, does this influence propagate to the wider academic community through scholarly associations? Specifically, we analyzed a set of retracted articles indexed in Thomson Reuters Web of Science (WoS), and ran multiple experiments to compare changes in scholarly impact against a control set of non-retracted articles, authors, and institutions. We further applied the Granger Causality test to investigate whether different scientific topics are dynamically affected by retracted papers occurring within those topics. Our results show two key findings: first, the scholarly impact of retracted papers and authors significantly decreases after retraction, and the most severe impact decrease correlates to retractions based on proven purposeful scientific misconduct; second, this retraction penalty does not seem to spread through the broader scholarly social graph, but instead has a limited and localized effect. Our findings may provide useful insights for scholars or science committees to evaluate the scholarly value of papers, authors, or institutions related to retractions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑