跨平台对参考文献的关注动态
Dynamics of Cross-Platform Attention to Retracted Papers
摘要:
在正式撤回之前,recruitment papers经常在社交媒体,数字新闻和其他网站上广泛传播。撤回论文中可能不准确或误导性结果的传播可能会损害科学界和公众。在这里,我们量化了不同在线平台上随着时间的推移收到的3,851篇撤回论文的关注量和类型。与来自相同期刊的一组非撤回对照论文相比,具有相似的出版年份,共同作者数量和作者影响力,我们发现撤回论文不仅在社交媒体上发表后受到更多关注,而且在新闻媒体和知识库等高度策划的平台上也受到更多关注,放大了对公众的负面影响。与此同时,我们发现Twitter上的帖子倾向于表达更多的批评收回比控制文件,这表明批评表达推文可能包含有关问题文件的事实信息。最重要的是,在论文被撤回的时候,论文引起的讨论主要是关于撤回事件,而不是关于研究结果,这表明到目前为止,论文已经耗尽了对其结果的关注,并突出了撤回的有限影响。我们的研究结果揭示了被撤回论文在不同在线平台上被讨论的程度,并确定了大规模的受众批评。在这种情况下,我们表明,撤回不是一个有效的工具,以减少在线关注有问题的论文。
英文摘要:
Retracted papers often circulate widely on social media, digital news and other websites before their official retraction. The spread of potentially inaccurate or misleading results from retracted papers can harm the scientific community and the public. Here we quantify the amount and type of attention 3,851 retracted papers received over time in different online platforms. Comparing to a set of non-retracted control papers from the same journals, with similar publication year, number of co-authors and author impact, we show that retracted papers receive more attention after publication not only on social media, but also on heavily curated platforms, such as news outlets and knowledge repositories, amplifying the negative impact on the public. At the same time, we find that posts on Twitter tend to express more criticism about retracted than about control papers, suggesting that criticism-expressing tweets could contain factual information about problematic papers. Most importantly, around the time they are retracted, papers generate discussions that are primarily about the retraction incident rather than about research findings, showing that by this point papers have exhausted attention to their results and highlighting the limited effect of retractions. Our findings reveal the extent to which retracted papers are discussed on different online platforms and identify at scale audience criticism towards them. In this context, we show that retraction is not an effective tool to reduce online attention to problematic papers.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。