arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2605.29367cs.CLcs.CYcs.SI
收藏

X平台上AI裁员话语中的注意力不对称性:资本与劳动放大的计算分析

Attention Asymmetry in AI Layoff Discourse on X: A Computational Analysis of Capital vs Labour Amplification

Independent Researcher(独立研究员)

Joy Bose

AI总结:

通过收集X平台推文,使用账户级收集方法发现资本话语的放大效应是劳动话语的3.12倍,经粉丝数标准化后仍存在2.69倍的不对称性,并引入放大比和放大归一化指数作为平台话语不平等的度量指标。

摘要:

当工人因AI驱动的重组而失业时,X(前Twitter)上同时发生两种截然不同的对话。科技高管和AI研究人员谈论生产力、转型和机遇。被解雇的工人和劳工批评者谈论失业、不确定性和恐惧。本文提出一个简单问题:哪种对话获得更多传播?我们报告了三项研究,使用两种收集方法和来自20个知名公共账户的763条推文。研究1使用基于关键词的收集(n=392),发现语料库之间无显著差异(p=0.891),表明关键词搜索对此任务噪声过大。研究2使用基于账户的收集(n=96),发现资本话语的平均放大优势是劳动话语的3.12倍(p=0.000003,Cohen's d=0.555)。研究3结合两种方法(n=763),确认了平均放大比4.18倍和中位数放大比10.77倍的结果(p<0.000001)。关键的是,在按粉丝数标准化后,不对称性仍然存在,为2.69倍(p=0.000009,Cohen's d=0.491),表明该效应并非仅仅是资本账户拥有更大受众的结果。该发现在所有测试的放大度量权重下均稳健。我们引入放大比和放大归一化指数作为衡量平台级话语不平等的简单指标。在Reddit上的跨平台复制(n=647条帖子)未复制该发现,表明不对称性可能特定于X基于账户的放大架构。我们讨论了跨平台话语分析的方法论意义。

英文摘要:

When workers lose jobs to AI-driven restructuring, two very different conversations happen on X (formerly Twitter) at the same time. Tech executives and AI researchers talk about productivity, transformation, and opportunity. Laid-off workers and labour critics talk about job loss, uncertainty, and fear. This paper asks a simple question: which conversation gets more reach? We report three studies using two collection methods and 763 tweets from 20 named public accounts. Study 1 used keyword-based collection (n=392) and found no significant difference between corpora (p=0.891), revealing that keyword search is too noisy for this task. Study 2 used account-based collection (n=96) and found a 3.12x mean amplification advantage for capital discourse over labour discourse (p=0.000003, Cohen's d=0.555). Study 3 combined both methods (n=763) and confirmed the finding at 4.18x mean and 10.77x median amplification ratio (p<0.000001). Critically, after normalising for follower count, the asymmetry persists at 2.69x (p=0.000009, Cohen's d=0.491), demonstrating that the effect is not simply a consequence of capital accounts having larger audiences. The finding is robust across all tested amplification metric weightings. We introduce the Amplification Ratio and Amplification Normalisation Index as simple metrics for measuring platform-level discourse inequality. A cross-platform replication on Reddit (n=647 posts) did not replicate the finding, suggesting the asymmetry may be specific to X's account-based amplification architecture. We discuss the methodological implications for cross-platform discourse analysis.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑