arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1312.7790astro-ph.COgr-qc
收藏

对A. Kumar

Comments on "Growth of Covariant Perturbations in the Contracting Phase of a Bouncing Universe" by A. Kumar

N. Pinto-Neto, S. D. P. Vitenti

摘要:

Kumar(2012)(以下简称K12)最近的一篇论文声称,在一个收缩模型中,由包含尘埃或辐射的坍缩弗里德曼模型周围的扰动描述,扰动可以以这样的方式增长,线性条件将变得无效。由于以下事实,该结论是不正确的:首先,声称不满足线性条件,但实际上在K12中没有估计扰动的幅度。因此,没有这样的估计,从这项工作的唯一可能的结论是众所周知的事实,即扰动确实在收缩期间增长,这本身并不意味着线性条件变得无效。第二,线性条件的一些评估是不正确的,因为第三,其他项,而不是适当的二阶项,被错误地与一阶项进行比较,产生人为的快速增长条件。最后,声称K12的结果与Vitenti和Pinto-Neto(2012)的论文(以下简称VPN 12)的结果形成鲜明对比,因为前者是以规范不变的方式获得的。然而,K12的作者没有意识到,在VPN 12中,微扰的演化也是以规范不变的方式计算的,但是一些需要检查的线性条件不能用规范不变量来表示。本文澄清和补充了K12中不正确或不完整的陈述,并表明K12的所有其他正确结果都已存在于VPN 12中,其结论保持不变,即,在一个弹跳模型中,源自量子力学的宇宙学扰动可以在一个很宽的能量尺度区间内,沿着收缩相和弹跳本身保持在线性状态的反弹。(摘要节略)

英文摘要:

A recent paper by Kumar (2012) (hereafter K12) claimed that in a contracting model, described by perturbations around a collapsing Friedmann model containing dust or radiation, the perturbations can grow in such a way that the linearity conditions would become invalid. This conclusion is not correct due to the following facts: first, it is claimed that the linearity conditions are not satisfied, but nowhere in K12 the amplitudes of the perturbations were in fact estimated. Therefore, without such estimates, the only possible conclusion from this work is the well known fact that the perturbations indeed grow during contraction, which, per se, does not imply that the linearity conditions become invalid. Second, some evaluations of the linearity conditions are incorrect because third other terms, instead of the appropriate second order ones, are mistakenly compared with first order terms, yielding artificially fast growing conditions. Finally, it is claimed that the results of K12 are in sharp contrast with the results of the paper by Vitenti and Pinto-Neto (2012) (hereafter VPN12), because the former was obtained in a gauge invariant way. However, the author of K12 did not realized that the evolution of the perturbations were also calculated in a gauge invariant way in VPN12, but some of the linearity conditions which are necessary to be checked cannot be expressed in terms of gauge invariant quantities. In the present work, the incorrect or incomplete statements of K12 are clarified and completed, and it is shown that all other correct results of K12 were already present in VPN12, whose conclusions remain untouched, namely, that cosmological perturbations of quantum mechanical origin in a bouncing model can remain in the linear regime all along the contracting phase and at the bounce itself for a wide interval of energy scales of the bounce. (Abstract abridged)

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑