We show that for any semi-random transposition shuffle on $n$ cards, the mixing time of any given $k$ cards is at most $n\log k$, provided $k=o((n/\log n)^{1/2})$. In the case of the top-to-random transposition shuffle we show that there is cutoff at this time with a window of size O(n), provided further that $k\to\infty$ as $n\to\infty$ (and no cutoff otherwise). For the random-to-random transposition shuffle we show cutoff at time $(1/2)n\log k$ for the same conditions on $k$. Finally, we analyse the cyclic-to-random transposition shuffle and show partial mixing occurs at time $\leαn\log k$ for some $α$ just larger than 1/2. We prove these results by relating the mixing time of $k$ cards to the mixing of one card. Our results rely heavily on coupling arguments to bound the total variation distance.
We study the cyclic adjacent transposition (CAT) shuffle of $n$ cards, which is a systematic scan version of the random adjacent transposition (AT) card shuffle. In this paper, we prove that the CAT shuffle exhibits cutoff at $\frac{n^3}{2 π^2} \log n$, which concludes that it is twice as fast as the AT shuffle.
In this thesis we introduce a new type of card shuffle called the one-sided transposition shuffle. At each step a card is chosen uniformly from the pack and then transposed with another card chosen uniformly from below it. This defines a random walk on the symmetric group generated by a distribution which is non-constant on the conjugacy class of transpositions. Nevertheless, we provide an explicit formula for all eigenvalues of the shuffle by demonstrating a useful correspondence between eigenvalues and standard Young tableaux. This allows us to prove the existence of a total-variation cutoff…
We introduce a new type of card shuffle called one-sided transpositions. At each step a card is chosen uniformly from the pack and then transposed with another card chosen uniformly from below it. This defines a random walk on the symmetric group generated by a distribution which is non-constant on the conjugacy class of transpositions. Nevertheless, we provide an explicit formula for all eigenvalues of the shuffle by demonstrating a useful correspondence between eigenvalues and standard Young tableaux. This allows us to prove the existence of a total-variation cutoff for the one-sided transpo…
In this paper we study the mixing time of a biased transpositions shuffle on a set of $N$ cards with $N/2$ cards of two types. For a parameter $0<a \le 1$, one type of card is chosen to transpose with a bias of $\frac{a}{N}$ and the other type is chosen with probability $\frac{2-a}{N}$. We show that there is cutoff for the mixing time of the chain at time $\frac{1}{2a} N \log N$. Our proof uses a modified marking scheme motivated by Matthews' proof of a strong uniform time for the unbiased shuffle.
We calculate a Ricci curvature lower bound for some classical examples of random walks, namely, a chain on a slice of the n-dimensional discrete cube (the so-called Bernoulli-Laplace model) and the random transposition shuffle of the symmetric group of permutations on n letters.
In this paper, we investigate the mixing time of the adjacent transposition shuffle for a deck of $N$ cards. We prove that around time $N^2\log N/(2π^2)$, the total variation distance to equilibrium of the deck distribution drops abruptly from $1$ to $0$, and that the separation distance has a similar behavior but with a transition occurring at time $(N^2\log N)/π^2$. This solves a conjecture formulated by David Wilson. We present also similar results for the exclusion process on a segment of length $N$ with $k$ particles.
Consider a permutation $σ\in S_n$ as a deck of cards numbered from 1 to $n$ and laid out in a row, where $σ_j$ denotes the number of the card that is in the $j$-th position from the left.\rm\ We define two cyclic to random transposition shuffles. The first one works as follows: for $j=1,..., n$, on the $j$-th step transpose the card that was \it originally\rm\ the $j$-th from the left with a random card (possibly itself). The second shuffle works as follows: on the $j$-th step, transpose the card that is \it currently\rm\ in the $j$-th position from the left with a random card (possibly itself…
In the cyclic-to-random shuffle, we are given n cards arranged in a circle. At step k, we exchange the k'th card along the circle with a uniformly chosen random card. The problem of determining the mixing time of the cyclic-to-random shuffle was raised by Aldous and Diaconis in 1986. Recently, Mironov used this shuffle as a model for the cryptographic system known as ``RC4'' and proved an upper bound of O(n log n) for the mixing time. We prove a matching lower bound, thus establishing that the mixing time is indeed of order $Θ(n \log n)$. We also prove an upper bound of O(n log n) for the mixi…
The Thorp shuffle is defined as follows. Cut the deck into two equal piles. Drop the first card from the left pile or the right pile according to the outcome of a fair coin flip; then drop from the other pile. Continue this way until both piles are empty. We show that the mixing time for the Thorp shuffle with $2^d$ cards is polynomial in $d$.
We prove an upper bound of $1.5324 n \log n$ for the mixing time of the random-to-random insertion shuffle, improving on the best known upper bound of $2 n \log n$. Our proof is based on the analysis of a non-Markovian coupling.
This paper explores the mixing time of the random transposition walk on permutations with one-sided interval restrictions. In particular, we're interested in the notion of cutoff, a phenomenon which occurs when mixing occurs in a window of order smaller than the mixing time. One of the main tools of the paper is the diagonalization obtained by Hanlon; the use of the spectral information is inspired by the famous paper of Diaconis and Shahshahani on the mixing time of the random transposition walk on the entire symmetric group. The diagonalization allows us to prove chi-squared cutoff for a bro…
We extend a technique for lower-bounding the mixing time of card-shuffling Markov chains, and use it to bound the mixing time of the Rudvalis Markov chain, as well as two variants considered by Diaconis and Saloff-Coste. We show that in each case Theta(n^3 log n) shuffles are required for the permutation to randomize, which matches (up to constants) previously known upper bounds. In contrast, for the two variants, the mixing time of an individual card is only Theta(n^2) shuffles.
The Card-Cyclic-to-Random shuffle on $n$ cards is defined as follows: at time $t$ remove the card with label $t$ mod $n$ and randomly reinsert it back into the deck. Pinsky introduced this shuffle and asked how many steps are needed to mix the deck. He showed $n$ steps do not suffice. Here we show that the mixing time is on the order of $Θ(n \log n)$.
This paper explores the mixing time of the random transposition walk on the symmetric group. While it has long been known that this walk mixes in order n*log(n) time, this result has not previously been attained using coupling. A coupling argument showing the correct order mixing time is presented. This is accomplished by first projecting to conjugacy classes, and then using the Bubley-Dyer path coupling construction. In order to obtain appropriate bounds on the time it takes the path coupling to meet, ideas from Schramm's paper "Compositions of Random Transpositions" are used.
E. Thorp introduced the following card shuffling model. Suppose the number of cards $n$ is even. Cut the deck into two equal piles. Drop the first card from the left pile or from the right pile according to the outcome of a fair coin flip. Then drop from the other pile. Continue this way until both piles are empty. We show that if $n$ is a power of 2 then the mixing time of the Thorp shuffle is $O(\log^3 n)$. Previously, the best known bound was $O(\log^4 n)$.
In the Gilbert-Shannon-Reeds shuffle, a deck of $N$ cards is cut into two approximately equal parts which are then riffled uniformly at random. Bayer and Diaconis famously showed that this Markov chain undergoes cutoff in total variation after $\frac{3\log(N)}{2 \log(2)}$ shuffles. We establish cutoff for the more general asymmetric riffle shuffles in which one cuts the deck into differently sized parts before riffling. The value of the cutoff point confirms a conjecture of Lalley from 2000. Some appealing consequences are that asymmetry always slows mixing and that total variation mixing is s…
The best known lower and upper bounds on the mixing time for the random-to-random insertions shuffle are $(1/2-o(1))n\log n$ and $(2+o(1))n\log n$. A long standing open problem is to prove that the mixing time exhibits a cutoff. In particular, Diaconis conjectured that the cutoff occurs at $3/4n\log n$. Our main result is a lower bound of $t_n = (3/4-o(1))n\log n$, corresponding to this conjecture. Our method is based on analysis of the positions of cards yet-to-be-removed. We show that for large $n$ and $t_n$ as above, there exists $f(n)=Θ(\sqrt{n\log n})$ such that, with high probability, un…
Motivated by Bourque and Pevzner's simulation study of the parsimony method for studying genome rearrangement, Berestycki and Durrett used techniques from random graph theory to prove that the minimum parsimony distance after iterating the random transposition shuffle undergoes a transition from Poisson to normal behavior. This paper establishes an analogous result for minimum parsimony distance after iterates of riffle shuffles or iterates of riffle shuffles and cuts. The analysis is elegant and uses different tools: Stein's method and generating functions. A useful technique which emerges is…
A deck of $n$ cards is shuffled by repeatedly moving the top card to one of the bottom $k_n$ positions uniformly at random. We give upper and lower bounds on the total variation mixing time for this shuffle as $k_n$ ranges from a constant to $n$. We also consider a symmetric variant of this shuffle in which at each step either the top card is randomly inserted into the bottom $k_n$ positions or a random card from the bottom $k_n$ positions is moved to the top. For this reversible shuffle we derive bounds on the $L^2$ mixing time. Finally, we transfer mixing time estimates for the above shuffle…
We prove a theorem that reduces bounding the mixing time of a card shuffle to verifying a condition that involves only pairs of cards, then we use it to obtain improved bounds for two previously studied models. E. Thorp introduced the following card shuffling model in 1973. Suppose the number of cards n is even. Cut the deck into two equal piles. Drop the first card from the left pile or from the right pile according to the outcome of a fair coin flip. Then drop from the other pile. Continue this way until both piles are empty. We obtain a mixing time bound of O(log^4 n). Previously, the best …
Consider the interchange process on a connected graph $G=(V,E)$ on $n$ vertices. I.e.\ shuffle a deck of cards by first placing one card at each vertex of $G$ in a fixed order and then at each tick of the clock, picking an edge uniformly at random and switching the two cards at the end vertices of the edge with probability 1/2. Well known special cases are the random transpositions shuffle, where $G$ is the complete graph, and the transposing neighbors shuffle, where $G$ is the $n$-path. Other cases that have been studied are the $d$-dimensional grid, the hypercube, lollipop graphs and Erd\H o…
We prove sharp rates of convergence to the Ewens equilibrium distribution for a family of Metropolis algorithms based on the random transposition shuffle on the symmetric group, with starting point at the identity. The proofs rely heavily on the theory of symmetric Jack polynomials, developed initially by Jack [Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A 69 (1970/1971) 1-18], Macdonald [Symmetric Functions and Hall Polynomials (1995) New York] and Stanley [Adv. Math. 77 (1989) 76-115]. This completes the analysis started by Diaconis and Hanlon in [Contemp. Math. 138 (1992) 99-117]. In the end we also ex…
We provide a coupling proof that the transposition shuffle on a deck of n cards is mixing of rate Cn(log{n}) with a moderate constant, C. This rate was determined by Diaconis and Shahshahani, but the question of a natural probabilistic coupling proof has been missing, and questions of its existence have been raised. The proof, and indeed any proof, requires that we enlarge the methodology of coupling to include intuitive but non-adapted coupling rules, because a typical Markovian coupling is incapable of resolving finer questions of rates.
The overhand shuffle is one of the ``real'' card shuffling methods in the sense that some people actually use it to mix a deck of cards. A mathematical model was constructed and analyzed by Pemantle [J. Theoret. Probab. 2 (1989) 37--49] who showed that the mixing time with respect to variation distance is at least of order $n^2$ and at most of order $n^2\log n$. In this paper we use an extension of a lemma of Wilson [Ann. Appl. Probab. 14 (2004) 274--325] to establish a lower bound of order $n^2\log n$, thereby showing that $n^2\log n$ is indeed the correct order of the mixing time. It is our …
In this paper, we investigate the properties of a random walk on the alternating group $A_n$ generated by $3$-cycles of the form $(i,n-1,n)$ and $(i,n,n-1)$. We call this the transpose top-$2$ with random shuffle. We find the spectrum of the transition matrix of this shuffle. We show that the mixing time is of order $\left(n-\frac{3}{2}\right)\log n$ and prove that there is a total variation cutoff for this shuffle.
We consider a random walk on the hyperoctahedral group $B_n$ generated by the signed permutations of the forms $(i,n)$ and $(-i,n)$ for $1\leq i\leq n$. We call this the flip-transpose top with random shuffle on $B_n$. We find the spectrum of the transition probability matrix for this shuffle. We prove that the mixing time for this shuffle is of order $n\log n$. We also show that this shuffle exhibits the cutoff phenomenon. In the appendix, we show that a similar random walk on the demihyperoctahedral group $D_n$ also has a cutoff at $\left(n-\frac{1}{2}\right)\log n$.
In this paper, we use the eigenvalues of the random to random card shuffle to prove a sharp upper bound for the total variation mixing time. Combined with the lower bound due to Subag, we prove that this walk exhibits cutoff at $\frac{3}{4} n \log n - \frac{1}{4}n\log\log{n}$ with window of order $n$, answering a conjecture of Diaconis.
Consider the random walk on the permutation group obtained when the step distribution is uniform on a given conjugacy class. It is shown that there is a critical time at which two phase transitions occur simultaneously. On the one hand, the random walk slows down abruptly (i.e., the acceleration drops from 0 to -\infty at this time as n tends to \infty). On the other hand, the largest cycle size changes from microscopic to giant. The proof of this last result is both considerably simpler and more general than in a previous result of Oded Schramm (2005) for random transpositions. It turns out t…
The card-cyclic-to-random shuffle is the card shuffle where the $n$ cards are labeled $1,\ldots,n$ according to their starting positions. Then the cards are mixed by first picking card $1$ from the deck and reinserting it at a uniformly random position, then repeating for card $2$, then for card $3$ and so on until all cards have been reinserted in this way. Then the procedure starts over again, by first picking the card with label $1$ and reinserting, and so on. Morris, Ning and Peres \cite{MNP} recently showed that the order of the number of shuffles needed to mix the deck in this way is $n\…
We prove tight bounds on the relaxation time of the so-called $L$-reversal chain, which was introduced by R. Durrett as a stochastic model for the evolution of chromosome chains. The process is described as follows. We have $n$ distinct letters on the vertices of the ${n}$-cycle (${\mathbb{Z}}$ mod $n$); at each step, a connected subset of the graph is chosen uniformly at random among all those of length at most $L$, and the current permutation is shuffled by reversing the order of the letters over that subset. We show that the relaxation time $τ(n,L)$, defined as the inverse of the spectral g…
By a well-known result of Bayer and Diaconis, the maximum entropy model of the common riffle shuffle implies that the number of riffle shuffles necessary to mix a standard deck of 52 cards is either 7 or 11--with the former number applying when the metric used to define mixing is the total variation distance and the latter when it is the separation distance. This and other related results assume all 52 cards in the deck to be distinct and require all $52!$ permutations of the deck to be almost equally likely for the deck to be considered well mixed. In many instances, not all cards in the deck…
Contingency tables are useful objects in statistics for representing 2-way data. With fixed row and column sums, and a total of $n$ entries, contingency tables correspond to parabolic double cosets of $S_n$. The uniform distribution on $S_n$ induces the Fisher-Yates distribution, classical for its use in the chi-squared test for independence. A Markov chain on $S_n$ can then induce a random process on the space of contingency tables through the double cosets correspondence. The random transpositions Markov chain on $S_n$ induces a natural `swap' Markov chain on the space of contingency tables;…
Bounding chains are a technique that offers three benefits to Markov chain practitioners: a theoretical bound on the mixing time of the chain under restricted conditions, experimental bounds on the mixing time of the chain that are provably accurate and construction of perfect sampling algorithms when used in conjunction with protocols such as coupling from the past. Perfect sampling algorithms generate variates exactly from the target distribution without the need to know the mixing time of a Markov chain at all. We present here the basic theory and use of bounding chains for several chains f…
We consider a random bistochastic matrix of size $n$ of the form $M Q$ where $M$ is a uniformly distributed permutation matrix and $Q$ is a given bistochastic matrix. Under mild sparsity and regularity assumptions on $Q$, we prove that the second largest eigenvalue of $MQ$ is essentially bounded by the normalized Hilbert-Schmidt norm of $Q$ when $n$ grows large. We apply this result to random walks on random regular digraphs and to shuffle-and-fold maps of the unit interval popularized in fluid mixing protocols.
In card games, in casino games with multiple decks of cards and in cryptography, one is sometimes faced with the following problem: how can a human (as opposed to a computer) shuffle a large deck of cards? The procedure we study is to break the deck into several reasonably sized piles, shuffle each thoroughly, recombine the piles, do some simple deterministic operation, for instance a cut, and repeat. This process can also be seen as a generalised Bernoulli-Laplace urn model. We use coupling arguments and spherical function theory to derive upper and bounds on the mixing times of these Markov …
Recently Wilson [Ann. Appl. Probab. 14 (2004) 274--325] introduced an important new technique for lower bounding the mixing time of a Markov chain. In this paper we extend Wilson's technique to find lower bounds of the correct order for card shuffling Markov chains where at each time step a random card is picked and put at the top of the deck. Two classes of such shuffles are addressed, one where the probability that a given card is picked at a given time step depends on its identity, the so-called move-to-front scheme, and one where it depends on its position. For the move-to-front scheme, a …
We present an overview of the representation theoretic techniques used to study the mixing times of random walks on finite groups. We focus on the card shuffle studied by Diaconis and Shahshahani in the 1980s and a recent improvement on their result by Teyssier
We find the total variation mixing time of the interchange process on the dumbbell graph (two complete graphs, $K_n$ and $K_m$, connected by a single edge), and show that this sequence of chains exhibits the cutoff phenomenon precisely when the smaller size $m$ goes to infinity. The mixing time undergoes a phase transition at $m\asymp \sqrt{n}$. We also state a conjecture on when exactly cutoff holds for the interchange process on general graphs. Our proofs use coupling methods, and they also give the mixing time of the simple exclusion process of $k$ labelled particles in the complete graph $…
