arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1301.7243physics.optics
收藏

对Scientific Reports 2,674中“线性和无源硅光隔离器”一文的评论

Comment on "Linear and passive silicon optical isolator" in Scientific Reports 2, 674

Alexander Petrov, Dirk Jalas, Manfred Eich, Wolfgang Freude, Shanhui Fan, Zongfu Yu, Roel Baets, Miloš Popović, Andrea Melloni, John D. Joannopoulos, Mathias Va… 展开作者

Alexander Petrov, Dirk Jalas, Manfred Eich, Wolfgang Freude, Shanhui Fan, Zongfu Yu, Roel Baets, Miloš Popović, Andrea Melloni, John D. Joannopoulos, Mathias Vanwolleghem, Christopher R. Doerr, Hagen Renner

摘要:

Wang等人[1]在模拟和实验中证明了前向和后向传播的不同功率传输系数。从这样的演示中,他们论文的中心主张是“空间反转对称性破缺二极管可以构建与任何互易原理不冲突的光隔离器”。他们的主张与洛伦兹互易定理相矛盾,众所周知,从洛伦兹互易定理出发,人们不能以这种方式构造隔离器。

英文摘要:

Wang et al. [1] demonstrated different power transmission coefficients for forward and backward propagation in simulation and experiment. From such a demonstration, the central claim of their paper is that "the spatial inversion symmetry breaking diode can construct an optical isolator in no conflict with any reciprocal principle". Their claim contradicts the Lorentz reciprocity theorem, from which it is well known that one cannot construct an isolator this way.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑