Indirect reciprocity is one of the main mechanisms to explain the emergence and sustainment of altruism in societies. The standard approach to indirect reciprocity are reputation models. These are games in which players base their decisions on their opponent's reputation gained in past interactions with other players (moral assessment). The combination of actions and moral assessment leads to a large diversity of strategies, thus determining the stability of any of them against invasions by all the others is a difficult task. We use a variant of a previously introduced reputation-based model that let us systematically analyze all these invasions and determine which ones are successful. Accordingly we are able to identify the third-order strategies (those which, apart from the action, judge considering both the reputation of the donor and that of the recipient) that are evolutionarily stable. Our results reveal that if a strategy resists the invasion of any other one sharing its same moral assessment, it can resist the invasion of any other strategy. However, if actions are not always witnessed, cheaters (i.e., individuals with a probability of defecting regardless of the opponent's reputation) have a chance to defeat the stable strategies for some choices of the probabilities of cheating and of being witnessed. Remarkably, by analyzing this issue with adaptive dynamics we find that whether a honest population resists the invasion of cheaters is determined by a Hamilton-like rule---with the probability that the cheat is discovered playing the role of the relatedness parameter.
Incomplete Reputation Information and Punishment in Indirect Reciprocity
Pukyong National University(釜庆国立大学);RIKEN Center for Interdisciplinary Theoretical and Mathematical Science (iTHEMS)(理化学研究所交叉理论数学科学中心(iTHEMS));RIKEN Center for Computational Science(理化学研究所计算科学中心)
University of Pennsylvania(宾夕法尼亚大学);RIKEN Center for Interdisciplinary Theoretical and Mathematical Science (iTHEMS)(理化学研究所交叉理论与数学科学中心(iTHEMS));RIKEN Center for Computational Science(理化学研究所计算科学中心);Saitama University(埼玉大学)