arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1102.4915math.STstat.TH
收藏

自适应分配设计是否有利于提高二进制响应试验的功效?

Are adaptive allocation designs beneficial for improving power in binary response trials?

David Azriel, Micha Mandel, Yosef Rinott

摘要:

我们考虑了经典的问题,选择最好的两个治疗的临床试验中的二元反应。目标是找到最大化相关测试功效的设计。许多文献使用幂函数的正态近似,并声称应使用根据响应的标准差的比率将受试者分配到治疗组的奈曼分配。由于标准差是未知的,因此通常建议采用自适应设计。这种方法的渐近理由是可验证的,因为它在尾部使用正态近似,其中近似的误差大于估计量。我们考虑两种不同的方法,最优性的设计是相关的皮特曼和巴哈杜尔定义的相对效率的测试。我们证明了根据Pitman准则的最优分配是平衡分配,根据Bahadur方法的最优分配取决于未知参数。精确的计算表明,根据Bahadur的最优分配往往接近于平衡设计,并且对于小样本量,两者的功效与Neyman分配相当,并且通常更适合于大实验。我们的研究结果有重要的影响,实验的设计,作为平衡设计被证明是最佳的或接近最佳的和需要的并发症涉及以下的自适应设计的目的,增加测试的权力,因此是值得怀疑的。

英文摘要:

We consider the classical problem of selecting the best of two treatments in clinical trials with binary response. The target is to find the design that maximizes the power of the relevant test. Many papers use a normal approximation to the power function and claim that Neyman allocation that assigns subjects to treatment groups according to the ratio of the responses' standard deviations, should be used. As the standard deviations are unknown, an adaptive design is often recommended. The asymptotic justification of this approach is arguable, since it uses the normal approximation in tails where the error in the approximation is larger than the estimated quantity. We consider two different approaches for optimality of designs that are related to Pitman and Bahadur definitions of relative efficiency of tests. We prove that the optimal allocation according to the Pitman criterion is the balanced allocation and that the optimal allocation according to the Bahadur approach depends on the unknown parameters. Exact calculations reveal that the optimal allocation according to Bahadur is often close to the balanced design, and the powers of both are comparable to the Neyman allocation for small sample sizes and are generally better for large experiments. Our findings have important implications to the design of experiments, as the balanced design is proved to be optimal or close to optimal and the need for the complications involved in following an adaptive design for the purpose of increasing the power of tests is therefore questionable.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑