arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv quant-ph/0202140quant-ph
收藏

关于“Klein-Gordon方程的类时能量动量流和粒子轨迹”的评论

Comment on ``Time-like flows of energy-momentum and particle trajectories for the Klein-Gordon equation''

Roderich Tumulka

摘要:

Horton、Dewney和Nesteruk [quant-ph/0103114]提出了闵可夫斯基空间中伴随Klein-Gordon波函数psi的玻姆型粒子轨迹。从时空上的两个向量场W^+和W^-(用psi定义)出发,他们打算构造一个类时向量场W,其积分曲线是可能的轨迹,其规则如下:在每个时空点,取W = W^+或W = W^-,取决于哪一个是类时的。然而,只要两者都是类时的,或者都是类空的,这个过程就不明确了。事实上,它们不可能都是类时的,但它们完全可以都是类空的,这与[quant-ph/0103114]的中心主张相反。我们指出了他们证明中的漏洞,提供了一个反例,并论证了即使对于一个相当任意的波函数,W^+和W^-都是类空的点也可以形成一个正测度集。

英文摘要:

Horton, Dewdney, and Nesteruk [quant-ph/0103114] have proposed Bohm-type particle trajectories accompanying a Klein-Gordon wave function psi on Minkowski space. From two vector fields on space-time, W^+ and W^-, defined in terms of psi, they intend to construct a timelike vector field W, the integral curves of which are the possible trajectories, by the following rule: at every space-time point, take either W = W^+ or W = W^- depending on which is timelike. This procedure, however, is ill-defined as soon as both are timelike, or both spacelike. Indeed, they cannot both be timelike, but they can well both be spacelike, contrary to the central claim of [quant-ph/0103114]. We point out the gap in their proof, provide a counterexample, and argue that, even for a rather arbitrary wave function, the points where both W^+ and W^- are spacelike can form a set of positive measure.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑