In this paper we discuss a genetic version (GWA) of the Whitehead's algorithm, which is one of the basic algorithms in combinatorial group theory. It turns out that GWA is surprisingly fast and outperforms the standard Whitehead's algorithm in free groups of rank >= 5. Experimenting with GWA we collected an interesting numerical data that clarifies the time-complexity of the Whitehead's Problem in general. These experiments led us to several mathematical conjectures. If confirmed they will shed light on hidden mechanisms of Whitehead Method and geometry of automorphic orbits in free groups.
We combine results about Whitehead groups of finite groups with results about genetic bases of finite $p$-groups to compute the Whitehead groups of some metacyclic $p$-groups. Let $C_{p^n}$ denote a cyclic group of order $p^n$ for $p$ an odd prime and $n$ a positive integer. We present a conjecture for the torsion part of the Whitehead group of $C_{p^n}\times C_{p^n}$ and we show that torsion part of the Whitehead group of the semidirect product of $C_{p^{n-1}}$ by $C_p$ is isomorphic to $C_p^{(n-2)(p-1)}$. The techniques we use can be applied to any abelian $p$-group and to many other $p$-gro…
Let p be an odd prime number. We describe the Whitehead group of all extra-special and almost extra-special p-groups. For this we compute, for any finite p-group P , the subgroup Cl\_1 (ZP) of SK\_1 (ZP), in terms of a genetic basis of P. We also introduce a deflation map Cl\_1 (ZP) $\rightarrow$ Cl\_1 (Z(P/N)) , for a normal subgroup N of P , and show that it is always surjective. Along the way, we give a new proof of the result describing the structure of SK\_1 (ZP), when P is an elementary abelian p-group.
J.H.C. Whitehead's second free-group algorithm determines whether or not two given elements of a free group lie in the same orbit of the automorphism group of the free group. The algorithm involves certain connected graphs, and Whitehead used three-manifold models to prove their connectedness; later, Rapaport and Higgins & Lyndon gave group-theoretic proofs. Combined work of Gersten, Stallings, and Hoare showed that the three-manifold models may be viewed as graphs. We give the direct translation of Whitehead's topological argument into the language of graph theory.
We develop a refinement of Whitehead's algorithm for primitive words in a free group. We generalize to subgroups, establishing a strengthened version of Whitehead's algorithm for free factors. We make use of these refinements in proving new results about primitive elements and free factors in a free group. These include a relative version of Whitehead's algorithm, and a criterion that tests whether a subgroup is a free factor just by looking at its primitive elements. We develop an algorithm to determine whether or not two vertices in the free factor complex have distance $d$ for $d=1,2,3$, as…
Using geodesic currents, we provide a theoretical justification for some of the experimental results regarding the behavior of Whitehead's algorithm on non-minimal inputs, that were obtained by Haralick, Miasnikov and Myasnikov via pattern recognition methods. In particular we prove that the images of "random" elements of a free group $F$ under the automorphisms of $F$ form "clusters" that share similar normalized Whitehead graphs and similar behavior with respect to Whitehead's algorithm.
We prove that there is an algorithm to determine whether a tuple of elements in a toral relatively hyperbolic group G is in the automorphic orbit of the other tuple.
In analogy with the free factors of a free group we define special factors of Generalized Baumslag-Solitar (GBS) groups as non-cyclic subgroups which appear in splittings over infinite cyclic groups. We give an algorithm which, given a GBS group $G$ and an element $g \in G$, decides whether there exists a special factor $H < G$ such that $g \in H$. This algorithm is analogous to an algorithm by Whitehead for free groups. Furthermore we prove that given $g \in G$ there exists a unique minimal special factor containing $g$ and give an algorithm which finds it.
The Whitehead Minimization problem is a problem of finding elements of the minimal length in the automorphic orbit of a given element of a free group. The classical algorithm of Whitehead that solves the problem depends exponentially on the group rank. Moreover, it can be easily shown that exponential blowout occurs when a word of minimal length has been reached and, therefore, is inevitable except for some trivial cases. In this paper we introduce a deterministic Hybrid search algorithm and its stochastic variation for solving the Whitehead minimization problem. Both algorithms use search heu…
The worst-case complexity of group-theoretic algorithms has been studied for a long time. Generic-case complexity, or complexity on random inputs, was introduced and studied relatively recently. In this paper, we address the average-case complexity (i.e., the expected runtime) of algorithms that solve a well-known problem, the Whitehead problem in a free group, which is: given two elements of a free group, find out whether there is an automorphism that takes one element to the other. First we address a special case of the Whitehead problem, namely deciding if a given element of a free group is…
Motivated by a question of Gordon and Wilton, we consider the question of which collections of words are "virtually geometric". In particular, we prove that some words (e.g. bbaaccabc) are not virtually geometric.
Let $F$ be any finite-rank free group, and $R$ be any finite subset of $\{g, [g]: g \in F-\{1\}\}$, where $[g]:= \{fgf^{-1}:f\in F\}$. By an $R$-allocating $F$-factorization we mean a set $\mathcal{H}$ of nontrivial subgroups of $F$ such that $\ast_{H \in \mathcal{H}} H = F$ and $R \subseteq \{h, [h] : h \in H, H\in \mathcal{H}\}$. We show that Whitehead's (fast) cutvertex algorithm inputs the pair $(F,R)$ and outputs a maximum-size $R$-allocating $F$-factorization. Richard Stong showed this in the case where $R \subseteq F$ or $R \subseteq \{[g] : g \in F\}$, thereby unifying and generalizing…
In this paper we discuss several heuristic strategies which allow one to solve the Whitehead's minimization problem much faster (on most inputs) than the classical Whitehead algorithm. The mere fact that these strategies work in practice leads to several interesting mathematical conjectures. In particular, we conjecture that the length of most non-minimal elements in a free group can be reduced by a Nielsen automorphism which can be identified by inspecting the structure of the corresponding Whitehead Graph.
The Whitehead minimization problem consists in finding a minimum size element in the automorphic orbit of a word, a cyclic word or a finitely generated subgroup in a finite rank free group. We give the first fully polynomial algorithm to solve this problem, that is, an algorithm that is polynomial both in the length of the input word and in the rank of the free group. Earlier algorithms had an exponential dependency in the rank of the free group. It follows that the primitivity problem -- to decide whether a word is an element of some basis of the free group -- and the free factor problem can …
S. Gersten announced an algorithm that takes as input two finite sequences $\vec K=(K_1,\dots, K_N)$ and $\vec K'=(K_1',\dots, K_N')$ of conjugacy classes of finitely generated subgroups of $F_n$ and outputs: (1) $\mathsf{YES}$ or $\mathsf{NO}$ depending on whether or not there is an element $θ\in \mathsf{Out}(F_n)$ such that $θ(\vec K)=\vec K'$ together with one such $θ$ if it exists and (2) a finite presentation for the subgroup of $\mathsf{Out}(F_n)$ fixing $\vec K$. S. Kalajdžievski published a verification of this algorithm. We present a different algorithm from the point of view of Culle…
We prove that Whitehead's algorithm for solving the automorphism problem in a fixed free group $F_k$ has strongly linear time generic-case complexity. This is done by showing that the ``hard'' part of the algorithm terminates in linear time on an exponentially generic set of input pairs. We then apply these results to one-relator groups. We obtain a Mostow-type isomorphism rigidity result for random one-relator groups: If two such groups are isomorphic then their Cayley graphs on the \emph{given generating sets} are isometric. Although no nontrivial examples were previously known, we prove tha…
Let $F$ be a finite-rank free group and $H$ be a finite-rank subgroup of $F$. We discuss proofs of two algorithms that sandwich $H$ between an upper-layer free-product factor of $F$ that contains $H$ and a lower-layer free-product factor of $F$ that is contained in $H$. Richard Stong showed that the unique smallest-possible upper layer, denoted $\operatorname{Cl}(H)$, is visible in the output of the polynomial-time cut-vertex algorithm of J. H. C. Whitehead. Stong's proof used bi-infinite paths in a Cayley tree and sub-surfaces of a three-manifold. We give a variant of his proof that uses edge…
We describe an implementation of a genetic algorithm on partially commutative groups and apply it to the double coset search problem on a subclass of groups. This transforms a combinatorial group theory problem to a problem of combinatorial optimisation. We obtain a method applicable to a wide range of problems and give results which indicate good behaviour of the genetic algorithm, hinting at the presence of a new deterministic solution and a framework for further results.
Let $F_n$ be the free group of a finite rank $n$. We study orbits $Orb_ϕ(u)$, where $u$ is an element of the group $F_n$, under the action of an automorphism $ϕ$. If an orbit like that is finite, we determine precisely what its cardinality can be if $u$ runs through the whole group $F_n$, and $ϕ$ runs through the whole group $Aut(F_n)$. Another problem that we address here is related to Whitehead's algorithm that determines whether or not a given element of a free group of finite rank is an automorphic image of another given element. It is known that the first part of this algorithm (reducing …
We study direct products of free-abelian and free groups with special emphasis on algorithmic problems. After giving natural extensions of standard notions into that family, we find an explicit expression for an arbitrary endomorphism of $\ZZ^m \times F_n$. These tools are used to solve several algorithmic and decision problems for $\ZZ^m \times F_n $: the membership problem, the isomorphism problem, the finite index problem, the subgroup and coset intersection problems, the fixed point problem, and the Whitehead problem.
