arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2606.15901cs.SIcs.CYcs.HC
收藏

挑战党派期望减少政治极化

Challenging Partisan Expectations Reduces Political Polarization

University of Maryland(马里兰大学);Observatory on Social Media, Indiana University Bloomington(印第安纳大学布卢明顿分校社交媒体观测站);Dresden University of Technology(德累斯顿工业大学)

Do Won Kim, Ozgur Can Seckin, Saumya Bhadani, Alessandro Flammini, Giovanni Luca Ciampaglia, Bao Tran Truong

AI总结:

通过实验发现,当对话违背党派身份与政策立场之间的预期关联时,能有效减少情感和议题极化,但效果在一个月后大多消失。

摘要:

政治对话常被提议作为政治极化的补救措施,但其有效性仍不一致。我们认为,这种不一致部分反映了政治接触中被忽视的一个特征:党派成员带入这些对话的期望。我们假设,当对话违背党派身份与议题立场之间的预期联系时,应能最大程度地减少政治极化。我们在一个2x2实验中测试了这一假设,其中1,983名美国成年人参与了一场与AI聊天机器人的结构化对话,该机器人的党派身份和政策立场被独立操纵。我们发现,挑战期望的对话——即参与者与持不同意见的内群体成员或持相同意见的外群体成员交谈——能有效减少情感和议题极化。尽管这些效果出现时参与者的自身政策立场没有实质性变化,但一项后续调查显示,大多数效果在一个月后消失。有趣的是,这些对话保持或改善了审议的客观指标,但参与者体验到的满意度较低。我们的研究结果将期望违背确定为一种未被充分探索的去极化机制。我们的结果也展示了对话AI作为实验研究缓解党派分歧干预措施的可扩展方法的潜力和局限性。

英文摘要:

Political conversations are often proposed as a remedy for political polarization, yet their effectiveness remains inconsistent. We argue that this inconsistency partly reflects a neglected feature of political contact: the expectations partisans bring to these encounters. We hypothesize that conversations should reduce political polarization the most when they violate the expected link between partisan identity and issue position. We test this hypothesis in a 2x2 experiment in which 1,983 U.S. adults engaged in structured conversations with an AI chatbot whose presented partisan identity and policy stance were independently manipulated. We find that expectation-challenging conversations in which participants talk with a disagreeing ingroup member or an agreeing outgroup member are effective in reducing affective and issue polarization. Although these effects emerge without meaningful shifts in participants' own policy positions, a follow-up survey shows that most effects disappear over one month. Interestingly, these conversations maintain or improve objective measures of deliberation but are experienced as less satisfying by participants. Our findings identify expectation violation as an underexplored depolarization mechanism. Our results also demonstrate the promises and limitations of how conversational AI can serve as a scalable method for experimentally studying interventions to mitigating partisan divides.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑