arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2605.22995cs.CYcs.AI
收藏

谁之善,谁之地?面向社会公益的能动型AI的道德地理学

Whose Good, Whose Place? The Moral Geography of Agentic AI for Social Good

University of North Texas(北卡罗来纳州立大学);Florida International University(佛罗里达国际大学)

Poli Nemkova, Haeshitha Indukuri, Jaedon Charles

AI总结:

通过调查112篇论文,发现面向社会公益的能动型AI存在道德地理不对称:论文在制度和社会政策领域最不指定地理背景,且仅25%报告实际部署,据此提出问责缺口和最低报告标准。

摘要:

能动型AI系统越来越多地被提出用于社会公益领域,通常引用联合国可持续发展目标(SDGs)作为全球利益的词汇。然而,社会公益的主张并未建立对系统声称服务的社区的问责。我们对2015年至2026年间发表的112篇关于社会公益的能动型AI论文进行了结构化调查。我们发现一种道德地理不对称:论文在最需要当地政治、法律和文化背景的领域最不可能指定地理背景。在整个语料库中,112篇论文中有82篇(73%)未指定任何地理背景。与健康或物理/生态SDGs相关的论文指定地理背景的比例为37-40%,而与制度和社会政策SDGs相关的论文仅13%。SDG 16(和平、正义与强大机构)既是语料库中覆盖最多的目标,也是地理指定率最低的目标。我们将此解释为道德抽象:面向社会公益的能动型AI往往将制度性善视为普适的,而不同于对待健康或生态善的方式。第二个发现加剧了这一点:112篇论文中只有28篇(25%)报告了任何实际部署或小规模测试。我们识别出五个问责缺口,并提出了一个最低报告标准,以促进更具体情境、参与性和负责任的面向社会公益的能动型AI。

英文摘要:

Agentic AI systems are increasingly proposed for social-good domains, often invoking the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) as a vocabulary of global benefit. Yet claims of social good do not establish accountability to the communities a system claims to serve. We present a structured survey of 112 papers on agentic AI for social good published between 2015 and 2026. We find a moral-geographic asymmetry: papers are least likely to specify geographic context in precisely the domains where local political, legal, and cultural context matters most. Across the corpus, 82 of 112 papers (73%) specify no geographic context. Papers aligned with health or physical/ecological SDGs specify geography 37-40% of the time, while papers aligned with institutional and social-policy SDGs do so only 13%. SDG 16, peace, justice, and strong institutions, is both the most-covered goal in the corpus and the one with the lowest geographic-specification rate. We interpret this as moral abstraction: agentic AI for social good often treats institutional good as universal in ways it does not treat health or ecological good. A second finding compounds this: only 28 of 112 papers (25%) report any real-world deployment or small-scale test. We identify five accountability gaps and propose a minimal reporting standard for more context-specific, participatory, and accountable agentic AI for social good.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑