人工智能研究者担心什么
What are AI researchers worried about?
AI总结:
人工智能研究者对AI的担忧与公众观点存在差异,但对风险评估和优先事项有趋同,研究揭示了AI研究者更注重实际风险而非极端威胁。
摘要:
随着人工智能吸引大量投资和关注,关于该技术的机会和不确定性存在竞争性关切,这些关切融合了技术和社会问题。公共辩论由少数强大声音主导,往往突出极端的承诺和威胁。我们想知道公众讨论或技术公司优先事项是否代表人工智能研究者的意见。我们对超过4000名人工智能研究者进行的调查,我们认为是迄今为止最大的一次。该调查旨在了解对各种问题的态度,并包含与现有调查中公众态度的比较。大多数以往对人工智能研究者进行的调查要求他们预测通过技术门槛或某些灾难性事件的概率。这些调查掩盖了通常特征于科学研究的不确定性和多样性。我们的假设是人工智能研究者的意见会与公众意见有显著差异。虽然在技术潜在好处的态度方面存在分歧,但我们的调查显示研究者和公众意见之间有一些令人惊讶的趋同,特别是在风险评估和优先事项方面。对开放文本问题“什么一件事最让你担心人工智能?”的回应显示,尽管媒体和政策中对这些风险的突出程度很高,但只有3%的人工智能研究者将存在风险作为优先事项。人工智能技术和人工智能研究者似乎比公众代表所暗示的要更加“正常”。我们的调查结果表明,存在新的公共对话形式的可能性,以讨论人工智能的危害、风险和机会。与其推测未来潜在风险,政策制定者和人工智能研究者应合作了解和缓解已经引起公众关注的各类社会技术风险。
英文摘要:
As AI attracts vast investment and attention, there are competing concerns about the technology's opportunities and uncertainties that blend technical and social questions. The public debate, dominated by a few powerful voices, tends to highlight extreme promises and threats. We wanted to know whether public discussions or technology companies' priorities were representative of AI researchers' opinions. Our survey of more than 4,000 AI researchers is, we think, the largest conducted to date. It was designed to understand attitudes to a variety of issues and include some comparisons with public attitudes derived from existing surveys. Most previous surveys of AI researchers have asked them for predictions of passing a technological threshold or the probabilities of some catastrophic event. These surveys mask the uncertainty and diversity that normally characterises scientific research. Our hypothesis was that the opinions of AI researchers would be markedly different from those of members of the public. While there are areas of divergence, particularly in attitudes to the technology's potential benefits, our survey shows some surprising convergence between researchers' and publics' opinions, particularly in the assessment and prioritisation of risk. Responses to an open text question 'What one thing most worries you about AI?' reveal that only 3% of AI researchers prioritise existential risks, despite the prominence given to these risks in media and policy. AI technologies and AI researchers seem to be much more 'normal' than public representations suggest. Our survey results suggest the possibility for new forms of public dialogue on AI's harms, risks and opportunities. Rather than speculating on future potential risks, policymakers and AI researchers should collaborate on understanding and mitigating the range of sociotechnical risks that are already of clear public concern.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。