阈值模型中集体行动的竞争性社会动员
Competitive Social Mobilization in Threshold Models of Collective Action
AI总结:
研究探讨了在有限参与者池中,不同参与阈值群体如何竞争形成共识,发现环境稳定性决定社会控制效果,高参与成本可能促进统一或破坏集体行动。
摘要:
社会动员常常不是因为缺乏集体利益而失败,而是由于竞争性运动之间对有限参与者池的激烈竞争。本文将经典集体行为阈值模型扩展,分析这种竞争性聚集,探讨具有不同参与阈值的人群如何在多个互斥原因中导航。聚焦于单个共识运动涵盖整个人口的必要条件,分析揭示社会竞争的结果取决于个体倾向的稳定性。在淬火环境中,参与阈值固定时,增加阻力最初允许主导运动压制竞争对手,但进一步阻力会突然导致完全碎片化。相反,在退火环境中,意见流动时,更高阻力反而驱动赢家通吃共识。在流体场景中,大规模运动只能通过有意的分而治之策略避免。在两种情况下,粉碎与大规模运动之间的过渡是不连续的。这些发现表明,社会控制的有效性完全取决于环境稳定性:提高参与成本可以促进统一或破坏集体行动。
英文摘要:
Social mobilization often fails not for a lack of collective interest, but because of fierce competition between rival movements for the same limited pool of participants. We generalize the classic threshold model of collective behavior to analyze this competitive aggregation, exploring how populations with diverse participation thresholds navigate multiple, mutually exclusive causes. Focusing on the conditions necessary for a single consensus movement to encompass an entire population, our analysis reveals that the outcome of social competition depends critically on the stability of individual dispositions. In quenched environments where participation thresholds are fixed, increasing resistance initially allows a dominant movement to suppress its competitors; however, further resistance triggers a sudden collapse into total fragmentation as low-threshold instigators become too rare to sustain growth. Conversely, in annealed environments where opinions are fluid, higher resistance paradoxically drives a winner-takes-all consensus. In this fluid scenario, massive movements can only be avoided through a deliberate divide-and-conquer strategy. In both cases, the transitions between pulverized and massive movements are discontinuous. These findings demonstrate that the effectiveness of social control depends entirely on environmental stability: raising the cost of participation can either forge unity or shatter collective action into insignificance.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。