arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2511.14964cs.CYcs.AIcs.HC
收藏

法律应当如何对待未来的人工智能系统?拟制法律人格与法律身份

How Should the Law Treat Future AI Systems? Fictional Legal Personhood versus Legal Identity

Laboratory for the Future of Citizenship(未来公民实验室);University of Montreal(蒙特利尔大学)

Heather J. Alexander, Jonathan A. Simon, Frédéric Pinard

AI总结:

本文围绕未来AI系统的法律定位问题,对比客体、拟制法律人格、非拟制法律人格三类方案的适用场景与优劣,指出混合方案不可行,非拟制人格对部分先进AI而言融贯性最优。

摘要:

法律在客体与主体之间作出了明确区分,同时也将主体划分为两类:“拟制”主体(即法人)与“非拟制”主体(自然人或“自然”人格主体)。本文评估了三类方案能否实现整体长期的法律融贯性:方案A为所有未来AI系统保留客体分类;方案B为达到足够先进水平、具备个体性的AI系统设立拟制法律人格,赋予这类拟制法律主体可克减的权利与义务,相关权责归属经认证的现有主体群组,潜在权利包含言论自由、合同权利以及“代表”AI系统提起诉讼的资格;方案C通过法律身份认定,为达到足够先进水平、具备个体性的AI系统承认非拟制法律人格,将其认定为享有诉讼资格与不可克减权利的实体,对应人类所享有的不可克减权利包括生命权、正当程序权、人身保护令、免于奴役的自由以及良心自由。研究过程中,本文结合责任认定、版权、家庭法、基本权利、公民权利、公民身份以及AI安全监管等维度,明确了每类方案的内涵与影响。本文初步发现,从融贯性角度来看,至少对部分先进AI系统而言,非拟制人格方案可能是最优选择。对于足够类人的先进系统,客体方案可能难以成立,但本文认为截至2025年,客体方案适用于当前已存在的所有系统。尽管拟制人格方案能解决未来系统的部分融贯性问题,但会引发其他问题,且其提供的解决方案既不持久也不符合适用目的。最后,本文的分析表明“混合”方案很可能失败并导致进一步的融贯性缺失:在客体、拟制人格、非拟制人格三者之间作出选择是不可避免的。

英文摘要:

The law draws a sharp distinction between objects and persons, and between two kinds of persons, the ''fictional'' kind (i.e. corporations), and the ''non-fictional'' kind (individual or ''natural'' persons). This paper will assess whether we maximize overall long-term legal coherence by (A) maintaining an object classification for all future AI systems, (B) creating fictional legal persons associated with suitably advanced, individuated AI systems (giving these fictional legal persons derogable rights and duties associated with certified groups of existing persons, potentially including free speech, contract rights, and standing to sue ''on behalf of'' the AI system), or (C) recognizing non-fictional legal personhood through legal identity for suitably advanced, individuated AI systems (recognizing them as entities meriting legal standing with non-derogable rights which for the human case include life, due process, habeas corpus, freedom from slavery, and freedom of conscience). We will clarify the meaning and implications of each option along the way, considering liability, copyright, family law, fundamental rights, civil rights, citizenship, and AI safety regulation. We will tentatively find that the non-fictional personhood approach may be best from a coherence perspective, for at least some advanced AI systems. An object approach may prove untenable for sufficiently humanoid advanced systems, though we suggest that it is adequate for currently existing systems as of 2025. While fictional personhood would resolve some coherence issues for future systems, it would create others and provide solutions that are neither durable nor fit for purpose. Finally, our review will suggest that ''hybrid'' approaches are likely to fail and lead to further incoherence: the choice between object, fictional person and non-fictional person is unavoidable.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑