arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2602.17932cs.CY
收藏

可操作代理:一种渗透性法律虚构,用于追踪AI系统中的过失

Operational Agency: A Permeable Legal Fiction for Tracing Culpability in AI Systems

Avyayam Holdings;Singapore Management University(新加坡管理大学)

Anirban Mukherjee, Hannah Hanwen Chang

AI总结:

本文提出可操作代理(OA)和可操作代理图(OAG)作为追踪AI系统过失的法律框架,通过分析AI的操作特征和因果关系,为法院和立法提供证据方法,确保人类问责制与技术自主性同步。

摘要:

现代人工智能(AI)系统在高度独立性方面表现出色,但缺乏法人身份——一个悖论,这破坏了以人类为中心的过失(mens rea)和行为(actus reus)为基础的法理。本文引入了可操作代理(OA)——一种渗透性法律虚构,结构上作为事后证据框架,并且可操作代理图(OAG),一种用于映射人类行为者、组织和AI系统之间因果互动的工具。OA评估AI的可观察操作特征:其目标导向性(作为意图的代理)、预测处理(作为预见的代理)和安全架构(作为照顾标准的代理)。OAG通过将这些特征嵌入因果图中,以追踪和分配开发者、微调者、部署者和用户之间的过失。借鉴公司刑事责任、无过失代理 doctrine、二次和间接责任框架,本文展示了OA和OAG如何加强现有法理。在五个现实世界案例研究中,涵盖侵权、民事权利、宪法法和反垄断法,它展示了该框架如何解决从自动驾驶碰撞到算法价格操纵等挑战,为法院提供了一种有原则的证据方法,并为立法和行业提供了一个概念基础,以确保人类问责制与技术自主性同步,而不赋予AI法人身份。

英文摘要:

Modern artificial intelligence (AI) systems act with a high degree of independence yet lack legal personhood-a paradox that fractures doctrines grounded in human-centric notions of mens rea and actus reus. This Article introduces Operational Agency (OA)-a permeable legal fiction structured as an ex post evidentiary framework-and Operational Agency Graph (OAG), a tool for mapping causal interactions among human actors, organizations, and AI systems. OA evaluates an AI's observable operational characteristics: its goal-directedness (as a proxy for intent), predictive processing (as a proxy for foresight), and safety architecture (as a proxy for a standard of care). OAG operationalizes that analysis by embedding these characteristics in a causal graph to trace and apportion culpability among developers, fine-tuners, deployers, and users. Drawing on corporate criminal liability, the innocent-agent doctrine, and secondary and vicarious liability frameworks, the Article shows how OA and OAG strengthen existing doctrines. Across five real-world case studies spanning tort, civil rights, constitutional law, and antitrust, it demonstrates how the framework addresses challenges ranging from autonomous vehicle collisions to algorithmic price-fixing, offering courts a principled evidentiary method-and legislatures and industry a conceptual foundation-to ensure human accountability keeps pace with technological autonomy, without conferring personhood on AI.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑