arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2511.02895cs.CYcs.AIcs.HCphysics.soc-ph
收藏

机器犯罪学

A Criminology of Machines

Fondazione Bruno Kessler(布鲁诺·科斯勒基金会)

Gian Maria Campedelli

AI总结:

本文提出“机器犯罪学”视角,主张将自主AI智能体视为具有计算、社会和法律的能动性的实体,通过双重分类法分析多智能体AI系统交互可能产生的越轨或犯罪结果,并提出四个关键研究问题,呼吁犯罪学界积极参与AI安全与治理。

摘要:

尽管实现类人人工智能(AI)的可能性仍存在争议,但未来社会将以自主机器日益增多为特征的可能性很高。自主AI智能体已经在多个行业和数字环境中部署并活跃,除了人与人、人与机器的交互之外,机器与机器的交互也将变得越来越普遍。鉴于这些发展,我认为犯罪学必须开始应对这一转变对犯罪和社会控制的影响。借鉴行动者网络理论和伍尔加数十年前提出的机器社会学呼吁——这些框架随着生成式AI智能体的兴起而重新获得相关性——我主张犯罪学家应当超越仅将AI视为工具的观念。相反,AI智能体应被认可为具有涵盖计算、社会和法律的能动性的实体。基于AI安全方面的文献,我因此考察了多智能体AI系统兴起所带来的风险,提出了一个双重分类法来刻画AI智能体之间的交互可能产生越轨、违法或犯罪结果的渠道。随后,我提出并讨论了四个值得理论和实证关注的关键问题:(1)我们能否假设机器只会模仿人类?(2)为人类发展的犯罪理论是否足以解释自主AI智能体之间交互中出现的越轨或犯罪行为?(3)哪些类型的犯罪行为会首先受到影响?(4)这一前所未有的社会转变将如何影响警务工作?这些问题凸显了犯罪学家迫切需要在理论和实证上参与多智能体AI系统对犯罪研究的影响,并在AI安全与治理的辩论中发挥更积极的作用。

英文摘要:

While the possibility of reaching human-like Artificial Intelligence (AI) remains controversial, the likelihood that the future will be characterized by a society with a growing presence of autonomous machines is high. Autonomous AI agents are already deployed and active across several industries and digital environments and alongside human-human and human-machine interactions, machine-machine interactions are poised to become increasingly prevalent. Given these developments, I argue that criminology must begin to address the implications of this transition for crime and social control. Drawing on Actor-Network Theory and Woolgar's decades-old call for a sociology of machines -- frameworks that acquire renewed relevance with the rise of generative AI agents -- I contend that criminologists should move beyond conceiving AI solely as a tool. Instead, AI agents should be recognized as entities with agency encompassing computational, social, and legal dimensions. Building on the literature on AI safety, I thus examine the risks associated with the rise of multi-agent AI systems, proposing a dual taxonomy to characterize the channels through which interactions among AI agents may generate deviant, unlawful, or criminal outcomes. I then advance and discuss four key questions that warrant theoretical and empirical attention: (1) Can we assume that machines will simply mimic humans? (2) Will crime theories developed for humans suffice to explain deviant or criminal behaviors emerging from interactions between autonomous AI agents? (3) What types of criminal behaviors will be affected first? (4) How might this unprecedented societal shift impact policing? These questions underscore the urgent need for criminologists to theoretically and empirically engage with the implications of multi-agent AI systems for the study of crime and play a more active role in debates on AI safety and governance.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑