论受控变革:生成式人工智能对新闻业职业权威的影响
On Controlled Change: Generative AI's Impact on Professional Authority in Journalism
AI总结:
本文基于对荷兰媒体从业者的13次访谈,提出“受控变革”概念,揭示记者通过制定指南、试验工具和批判评估三种机制,以受监督方式整合生成式AI,维护职业权威。
摘要:
在新闻业中使用(生成式)人工智能工具和系统,预计将提高记者的生产效率,改变新闻编辑室的经济模式,并进一步个性化受众的新闻消费实践。自2022年发布以来,OpenAI的ChatGPT和其他大型语言模型已在新闻组织内部拉响警报,不仅因为这些技术给新闻报道和事实核查带来了新挑战,还因为它们对记者在新闻业中的职业权威意味着什么。本文考察了荷兰媒体的记者如何将人工智能技术的整合管理到他们的日常工作中。基于对来自不同新闻机构和媒体公司的编辑、记者和创新经理的13次访谈,我们提出了“受控变革”这一概念,作为解释记者如何主动制定指南、试验人工智能工具并识别其局限性与能力的启发式框架。以职业权威作为理论框架,我们认为记者以受监督的方式预期并整合人工智能技术,并识别出记者管理这一整合的三种主要机制:(1)制定适应性指南,使人工智能的使用与道德准则保持一致;(2)试验人工智能技术以确定其必要性和契合度;(3)批判性地评估人工智能系统的能力与局限性。
英文摘要:
Using (generative) artificial intelligence tools and systems in journalism is expected to increase journalists' production rates, transform newsrooms' economic models, and further personalize the audience's news consumption practices. Since its release in 2022, OpenAI's ChatGPT and other large language models have raised the alarms inside news organizations, not only for bringing new challenges to news reporting and fact-checking but also for what these technologies would mean for journalists' professional authority in journalism. This paper examines how journalists in Dutch media manage the integration of AI technologies into their daily routines. Drawing from 13 interviews with editors, journalists, and innovation managers in different news outlets and media companies, we propose the concept of controlled change. as a heuristic to explain how journalists are proactively setting guidelines, experimenting with AI tools, and identifying their limitations and capabilities. Using professional authority as a theoretical framework, we argue that journalists anticipate and integrate AI technologies in a supervised manner and identify three primary mechanisms through which journalists manage this integration: (1) developing adaptive guidelines that align AI use with ethical codes, (2) experimenting with AI technologies to determine their necessity and fit, and (3) critically assessing the capabilities and limitations of AI systems.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。