超越益处:生成式AI在计算机教育中的危害与后果的系统性综述
Beyond the Benefits: A Systematic Review of the Harms and Consequences of Generative AI in Computing Education
AI总结:
该研究针对GenAI在计算机教育中的风险危害开展系统性综述,检索筛选224篇文献分析危害类别与规律,指出研究空白,为相关群体提供危害全景参考。
摘要:
生成式人工智能(GenAI)已对计算机教育产生重大影响,既往研究已明确其诸多益处。然而,近期研究也发现了潜在风险与危害。为在应对危害及意外后果的同时持续最大化AI的益处,我们针对聚焦GenAI在计算机教育中的风险、危害及意外后果的研究开展了系统性文献综述。我们检索了ACM DL、IEEE Xplore和Scopus数据库2022-2025年的文献,共得到1677篇论文,随后根据纳入与排除标准筛选出224篇。遵循系统性综述的最佳实践,4名评审员独立提取每篇论文的发表年份、学习者群体、研究方法、贡献类型、GenAI技术及教育任务信息。随后我们对每篇论文进行编码,划分出学术诚信、认知影响、信任问题等具体危害类别。我们的分析揭示了危害出现的方式与场景的规律,指出了方法学上的空白以及获取更严谨证据的机遇,还识别出了尚未被充分探究的危害类型与学生群体。通过综合这些洞见,我们旨在让教育工作者、计算机专业学生、研究者及开发者清晰了解GenAI在计算机教育中相关的危害。
英文摘要:
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has already had a big impact on computing education with prior research identifying many benefits. However, recent studies have also identified potential risks and harms. To continue maximizing AI benefits while addressing the harms and unintended consequences, we conducted a systematic literature review of research focusing on the risks, harms, and unintended consequences of GenAI in computing education. Our search of ACM DL, IEEE Xplore, and Scopus (2022-2025) resulted in 1,677 papers, which were then filtered to 224 based on our inclusion and exclusion criteria. Guided by best practices for systematic reviews, four reviewers independently extracted publication year, learner population, research method, contribution type, GenAI technology, and educational task information from each paper. We then coded each paper for concrete harm categories such as academic integrity, cognitive effects, and trust issues. Our analysis shows patterns in how and where harms appear, highlights methodological gaps and opportunities for more rigorous evidence, and identifies under-explored harms and student populations. By synthesizing these insights, we intend to equip educators, computing students, researchers, and developers with a clear picture of the harms associated with GenAI in computing education.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。