arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2411.00699cs.HCcs.AI
收藏

预测支持系统中的算法透明性

Algorithmic Transparency in Forecasting Support Systems

Institute for Business, Christian-Albrechts-University Kiel(商业研究所,基尔基督教阿尔布雷希茨大学)

Leif Feddersen

AI总结:

本文探讨了预测支持系统中算法透明度对预测调整的影响,发现透明度可减少有害调整,但过度透明可能导致用户压力,非透明系统更受用户青睐。

摘要:

大多数组织手动调整其统计预测(例如销售预测)。预测支持系统(FSS)使相关过程自动化预测生成和手动调整成为可能。由于FSS用户界面连接用户和统计算法,因此它显然是促进有益调整的同时阻止有害调整的明显杠杆。本文回顾并组织了关于判断性预测、预测调整和FSS设计的文献。我主张算法透明可能是实现更好、更整合预测的关键因素,并通过三种不同透明度的FSS设计进行测试。我发现透明度可以减少有害预测调整的方差和数量。然而,让用户自己调整算法的透明组件会导致广泛变化且总体上最有害的调整。回应表明,没有充分培训的情况下,算法透明可能会让用户感到压力。因此,自我报告的满意度最高的是非透明的FSS。

英文摘要:

Most organizations adjust their statistical forecasts (e.g. on sales) manually. Forecasting Support Systems (FSS) enable the related process of automated forecast generation and manual adjustments. As the FSS user interface connects user and statistical algorithm, it is an obvious lever for facilitating beneficial adjustments whilst discouraging harmful adjustments. This paper reviews and organizes the literature on judgemental forecasting, forecast adjustments, and FSS design. I argue that algorithmic transparency may be a key factor towards better, integrative forecasting and test this assertion with three FSS designs that vary in their degrees of transparency based on time series decomposition. I find transparency to reduce the variance and amount of harmful forecast adjustments. Letting users adjust the algorithm's transparent components themselves, however, leads to widely varied and overall most detrimental adjustments. Responses indicate a risk of overwhelming users with algorithmic transparency without adequate training. Accordingly, self-reported satisfaction is highest with a non-transparent FSS.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑