穿越算法隐匿性:半自动驾驶车辆中用户自主性的folk理论
Navigating Algorithmic Opacity: Folk Theories and User Agency in Semi-Autonomous Vehicles
AI总结:
研究探讨了半自动驾驶车辆司机如何通过folk理论理解算法行为,揭示了司机在算法治理中的被动地位,并提出参与式算法治理框架以提升透明度和用户参与度。
摘要:
随着半自动驾驶车辆(AVs)的普及,司机必须与决策过程仍不透明的AI系统协作。本研究探讨了AV司机如何发展folk理论来解释与他们预期相矛盾的算法行为。通过与美国16名司机进行半结构化访谈,我们调查了司机为理解AI决策所构建的解释框架,当系统行为意外时所采用的策略,以及他们与控制交接和反馈机制的经历。我们的发现表明,司机发展出复杂的folk理论——通常使用拟人化隐喻描述系统“看见”、“犹豫”或“不堪重负”——但缺乏验证这些理论或有意义参与算法治理的信息资源。我们识别出算法隐匿性表现剧烈的场景,包括复杂交叉口、恶劣天气和农村环境。当前AV设计将司机定位为被动的数据来源,而非知识主体,造成问责空白,削弱信任和安全。基于批判性数据研究和算法问责文献,我们提出一个参与式算法治理框架,以提供司机对AI决策过程的透明度,并提供有意义的渠道参与系统改进。本研究有助于理解用户如何在安全关键情境中导航数据化的社会技术系统。
英文摘要:
As semi-autonomous vehicles (AVs) become prevalent, drivers must collaborate with AI systems whose decision-making processes remain opaque. This study examines how drivers of AVs develop folk theories to interpret algorithmic behavior that contradicts their expectations. Through 16 semi-structured interviews with drivers in the United States, we investigate the explanatory frameworks drivers construct to make sense of AI decisions, the strategies they employ when systems behave unexpectedly, and their experiences with control handoffs and feedback mechanisms. Our findings reveal that drivers develop sophisticated folk theories -- often using anthropomorphic metaphors describing systems that ``see,'' ``hesitate,'' or become ``overwhelmed'' -- yet lack informational resources to validate these theories or meaningfully participate in algorithmic governance. We identify contexts where algorithmic opacity manifests acutely, including complex intersections, adverse weather, and rural environments. Current AV designs position drivers as passive data sources rather than epistemic agents, creating accountability gaps that undermine trust and safety. Drawing on critical data studies and algorithmic accountability literature, we propose a framework for participatory algorithmic governance that would provide drivers with transparency into AI decision-making and meaningful channels for contributing to system improvement. This research contributes to understanding how users navigate datafied sociotechnical systems in safety-critical contexts.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。