arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2408.12083physics.ed-phphysics.data-an
收藏

工程与物理科学专业学生的主要迷思概念及冲积流分析

Dominant misconceptions and alluvial flows between Engineering and Physical Science students

Anna Chrysostomou, Alan S. Cornell, Wade Naylor

AI总结:

该研究以约翰内斯堡大学大一工程与物理科学专业学生为对象,结合力概念清单测试数据与冲积图等工具分析物理概念迷思,发现工程生平均表现更优,但两类学生均存在持续性迷思,且物理科学生的答题选择更混乱。

摘要:

本文评估了2022年南非约翰内斯堡大学(UJ)第一学期在读的物理科学与工程专业学生对物理概念的理解情况。我们采用多种图形化测度方法,基于Force Concept Inventory(力概念清单)评估工具的前测与后测数据结果,探究两类学生的异同,据此计算出主要迷思概念(DMs)与概念增益。我们还使用冲积图追踪这两组学生从前测到后测阶段的选项选择情况。分析结果显示,主要迷思概念数据表明,参与研究的工程专业学生平均表现优于物理科学专业学生,但同类标准化主要迷思概念在后测阶段仍然存在,我们将这类迷思概念称为“持续性迷思概念”。这一发现对追踪持续性迷思概念极具价值;当采用重复测量法并针对更小的学生群体使用冲积图时,我们发现物理科学专业学生的选项选择往往更具随机性。

英文摘要:

In this article we assess the comprehension of physics concepts by Physical Science and Engineering students enrolled in their first semester at the University of Johannesburg (UJ), South Africa ($2022$). We employ different graphical measures to explore similarities and differences using the results of both pre- and post-test data from the Force Concept Inventory assessment tool, from which we calculate dominant misconceptions (DMs) and gains. We also use alluvial diagrams to track the choices made by these two groups of students from pre- to post-test stages. In our analysis, we find that DM results indicate that participating Engineering students outperformed Physical Science students on average, however, the same types of normalised DMs persist at the post-test level. We call these DMs "persistent misconceptions." This is very useful when tracking persistent misconceptions, where when using repeated measures and alluvial diagrams with smaller groups of students, we find that Physical Science students tend to make more chaotic choices.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑