arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2407.15591cs.CYcs.DB
收藏

十个广泛使用的化学数据集的FAIR评估:经验教训与建议

FAIR evaluation of ten widely used chemical datasets: Lessons learned and recommendations

Marcos Da Silveira, Oona Freudenthal, Louis Deladiennee

AI总结:

本文评估了北美和欧洲十个化学数据集的FAIR性,采用手动问卷与自动工具互补方法,发现自动评分最高仅54/100,并指出元数据缺失或格式非标准导致自动检测失败,最后给出改进建议。

摘要:

本文档聚焦于传播北美和欧洲(欧盟)市场上发现的(有害)物质数据的数据库。目标是分析这些物质已发布开放数据的FAIR性(可发现性、可访问性、互操作性和可重用性),并定性评估所选数据库在多大程度上已满足委员会关于化学品数据通用平台法规草案中设定的标准。我们实施了两种互补的方法:手动方法和自动方法。手动方法基于在线问卷。这些问卷通过引导用户回答一系列与FAIR原则相关的问题,提供了一种结构化的FAIR性评估方法。它们特别适用于在研究团队内发起关于FAIR实施的讨论,并识别需要进一步关注的领域。用于FAIR性评估的自动化工具,如F-UJI和FAIR Checker,正日益受到重视并持续开发中。与手动工具不同,自动化工具从待评估数据资源的可解引用URL开始,自动执行一系列测试。我们分析了在欧洲和北美管理的十个广泛采用的数据集。自动分析的最高得分为54/100。手动分析显示,若干FAIR指标得到满足,但自动化工具无法检测到,因为缺少元数据,或信息格式不是标准格式。因此,工具无法解释这些信息。我们提供了分析的详细内容以及总结结果、问题和解决这些问题的建议的表格。

英文摘要:

This document focuses on databases disseminating data on (hazardous) substances found on the North American and the European (EU) market. The goal is to analyse the FAIRness (Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability and Reusability) of published open data on these substances and to qualitatively evaluate to what extend the selected databases already fulfil the criteria set out in the commission draft regulation on a common data chemicals platform. We implemented two complementary approaches: Manual, and Automatic. The manual approach is based on online questionnaires. These questionnaires provide a structured approach to evaluating FAIRness by guiding users through a series of questions related to the FAIR principles. They are particularly useful for initiating discussions on FAIR implementation within research teams and for identifying areas that require further attention. Automated tools for FAIRness assessment, such as F-UJI and FAIR Checker, are gaining prominence and are continuously under development. Unlike manual tools, automated tools perform a series of tests automatically starting from a dereferenceable URL to the data resource to be evaluated. We analysed ten widely adopted datasets managed in Europe and North America. The highest score from automatic analysis was 54/100. The manual analysis shows that several FAIR metrics were satisfied, but not detectable by automatic tools because there is no metadata, or the format of the information was not a standard one. Thus, it was not interpretable by the tool. We present the details of the analysis and tables summarizing the outcomes, the issues, and the suggestions to address these issues.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑