arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2605.02773cs.CY
收藏

AI伦理的批判实用主义方法:来自城市规划理论的启示

A Critical Pragmatism Approach for AI Ethics: Lessons from Urban Planning Theory

Cornell Tech(康奈尔科技);Cornell University(康奈尔大学)

Jennah Gosciak, Karen Levy, Allison Koenecke

AI总结:

本文将算法公平性视为“棘手问题”,借鉴城市规划的批判实用主义理论,提出灵活建议并应用于三个案例,为AI伦理实践提供整体解决方案。

摘要:

当数据科学家在机器学习(ML)与算法设计中应对日益复杂的伦理决策时,AI伦理领域的学术研究已提供了多种解决方案,从公平性的形式化数学定义到来自不同学科的整体公平框架。然而,在实践中开发符合伦理且公平的算法系统仍是持续存在的挑战。本文将算法公平性问题与城市规划问题进行类比,将算法公平性问题界定为“棘手问题”——该术语源自规划与政策领域,用于描述这类工作难以处理、充满价值负载且性质复杂的特征。因此,本文认为AI伦理领域可从城市规划的理论研究中学习,以缓解自身的一系列棘手问题。城市规划通常关注治理、资源分配、利益相关者参与以及涉及根深蒂固差异的冲突等实际问题,这些挑战是AI领域纯技术方法极易忽视的。本文基于批判实用主义的城市规划理论方法提出了一套灵活建议——批判实用主义是一种反思性、审议性的方法,用于应对棘手问题,会考虑从业者在面对冲突与权力时的实际行动。本文将这些建议应用于几个案例研究:自动抵押贷款发放、学校择校以及针对女性谋杀的反数据收集。研究人员与从业者可将这些源自城市规划的建议融入其正在开展的工作中,以更全面地解决与AI伦理相关的问题。

英文摘要:

As data scientists grapple with increasingly complex ethical decisions in machine learning (ML) and algorithm design, scholarship on AI ethics has offered multiple solutions, from formal mathematical definitions of fairness to holistic fairness frameworks drawn from various academic disciplines. Still, developing ethical and fair algorithmic systems in practice remains an ongoing challenge. In this paper, we draw a parallel between problems in algorithmic fairness and urban planning. We frame algorithmic fairness problems as `wicked problems,' a term originating from the planning and policy space to describe the intractable, value-laden, and complex nature of this work. As such, we argue that the field of AI ethics can learn from theoretical work in urban planning in ameliorating its own set of wicked problems. Urban planning is typically concerned with practical issues of governance, resource allocation, stakeholder engagement, and conflicts involving deep-seated differences. These are challenges that purely technical approaches in AI easily overlook. We present a flexible set of recommendations based on the urban planning theory approach of critical pragmatism --- a reflective and deliberative approach to addressing wicked problems that considers what practitioners actually do in the face of conflict and power. We apply our recommendations to several case studies: automated mortgage lending, school choice, and feminicide counterdata collection. Researchers and practitioners can incorporate these recommendations derived from urban planning into their ongoing work to more holistically address problems related to AI ethics.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑