arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2005.12087cs.CY
收藏

大流行期间的实验性、特设、在线、大学间学生电子竞赛:吸取的经验教训

Experimental, ad hoc, online, inter-university student e-contest during the pandemic: Lessons learned

Horia-Nicolai Teodorescu

摘要:

我们正在报告从当前疫情期间为学生举办的电子竞赛中吸取的经验教训。我们将电子竞赛与之前10个版本的面对面竞赛进行了比较。虽然竞争显然没有因为是虚拟竞争而受到影响,但也注意到了一些不利因素。主要结论如下:基本的互联方式没有产生严重的技术问题,但互联性比面对面的互联性更有限;在线评审-竞争对手互动性比面对面互动性差;人为因素,组织过程中的更高不确定性,以及当地组织者花费的时间更少是主要的限制因素;参与和评估公平性的关注更高;非自愿的性别歧视似乎较低,但仍然存在;存在与隐私有关的严重关切,包括差分隐私;所提出的主题和评价过程出现了一些特殊性,但不清楚这些特殊性是否与竞赛的在线性质有关,是否与大流行病期间参赛者承受的额外压力有关,是否与其他因素有关,或者是随机的。虽然有些结论可能与所分析的案例密切相关,但有些结论足够普遍,对其他在线比赛有价值。

英文摘要:

We are reporting on lessons learned from an e-contest for students held during the current pandemic. We compare the e-contest with the 10 previous editions of the same but face-to-face contest. While apparently the competition did not suffer because of being a virtual one, some disadvantages were noted. The main conclusions are: the basic interconnectivity means arise no serious technical issue, but the interconnectivity is more limited than the face-to-face one; online jury-competitors interactivity is poorer than face-to-face interactivity; human factors, higher uncertainties in the organization process, and less time to spend in the process for the local organizers are major limiting factors; concerns on the participation and evaluation fairness are higher; involuntary gender discrimination seems lower, but persists; there are serious concerns related to privacy, including differential privacy; some peculiarities of the presented topics and of the evaluation process emerged, but it is unclear if they are related to the online nature of the competition, to the extra stress on the participants during the pandemic, to other factors, or are random. While some conclusions may be intimately related to the analyzed case, some are general enough for being worth to other online competitions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑