arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2406.06143q-bio.NC
收藏

整合信息理论需要注意力

The Integrated Information Theory needs Attention

Azenet Lopez, Carlos Montemayor

AI总结:

本文指出整合信息理论(IIT)因忽视注意力在塑造意识体验中的关键作用而存在根本局限,主张IIT亟需引入注意力解释,并论证意识与注意力的双重分离与IIT不兼容。

摘要:

整合信息理论(IIT)可能是我們目前对现象意识进行科学解释的最佳选择。IIT 专注于意识体验中独特的主体性和现象学方面。目前,它提供了形式化解释的基础,但未来的发展应解释每种可能意识体验的定性结构。然而,这一雄心勃勃的项目受到一个根本局限性的阻碍。IIT 未能承认注意力在产生现象意识体验和塑造其内容方面的关键作用。在此,我们主张 IIT 迫切需要关于注意力的解释。没有这一解释,IIT 无法解释不同类型体验之间的重要信息差异。此外,尽管一些 IIT 支持者著名地赞同意识与注意力之间的双重分离,但仔细分析表明,这种分离实际上与 IIT 不兼容。值得注意的是,我们针对 IIT 提出的问题很可能也会出现在哲学中关于意识内容的许多内在主义理论上,尤其是带有原始主义倾向的理论。我们的论点也延伸到最近流行的结构主义方法。总体而言,我们的讨论强调了关于注意力的考量对于关于意识体验的科学和哲学理论化是不可或缺的。

英文摘要:

The Integrated Information Theory (IIT) might be our current best bet at a scientific explanation of phenomenal consciousness. IIT focuses on the distinctively subjective and phenomenological aspects of conscious experience. Currently, it offers the fundaments of a formal account, but future developments shall explain the qualitative structures of every possible conscious experience. But this ambitious project is hindered by one fundamental limitation. IIT fails to acknowledge the crucial roles of attention in generating phenomenally conscious experience and shaping its contents. Here, we argue that IIT urgently needs an account of attention. Without this account, IIT cannot explain important informational differences between different kinds of experiences. Furthermore, though some IIT proponents celebratedly endorse a double dissociation between consciousness and attention, close analysis reveals that such as dissociation is in fact incompatible with IIT. Notably, the issues we raise for IIT will likely arise for many internalist theories of conscious contents in philosophy, especially theories with primitivist inclinations. Our arguments also extend to the recently popularized structuralist approaches. Overall, our discussion highlights how considerations about attention are indispensable for scientific as well as philosophical theorizing about conscious experience.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑