设计人机系统:拟人化与框架效应对人机协作的影响
Designing Human-AI Systems: Anthropomorphism and Framing Bias on Human-AI Collaboration
AI总结:
本研究通过招聘场景中的3×3实验,发现拟人化显著影响用户对AI推荐的认同,而框架效应无显著影响,表明认知偏差影响人机协作,需定制化AI设计。
摘要:
人工智能正在重新定义人类与技术互动的方式,促成两者之间的协同合作。然而,人类认知对此类协作的影响仍不明确。本研究探讨了两种认知偏差——拟人化与框架效应——在招聘情境中对人机协作的影响。受试者被要求借助一个基于人工智能的推荐工具来挑选求职者。该工具采用3×3的受试者间设计进行操控,呈现三种不同的AI身份(类人型、机器人型、通用型)以及三种类型的框架(正面、负面和中性)。结果显示,AI推荐的框架对受试者的决策没有显著影响。相反,拟人化显著影响了受试者对AI推荐的认同程度。当AI具有类人特征时,受试者更倾向于不认同其推荐。这些发现表明,认知偏差能够影响人机协作,并凸显了针对AI产品设计采取定制化方法而非单一通用方案的必要性。
英文摘要:
AI is redefining how humans interact with technology, leading to a synergetic collaboration between the two. Nevertheless, the effects of human cognition on this collaboration remain unclear. This study investigates the implications of two cognitive biases, anthropomorphism and framing effect, on human-AI collaboration within a hiring setting. Subjects were asked to select job candidates with the help of an AI-powered recommendation tool. The tool was manipulated in a 3 x 3 between-subjects design to present three different AI identities (human-like, robot-like, generic) and three types of framing (positive, negative, and neutral). The results revealed that the framing of AI's recommendations had no significant influence on subjects' decisions. In contrast, anthropomorphism significantly affected subjects' agreement with AI recommendations. Subjects were less likely to agree with the AI if it had human-like characteristics. These findings demonstrate that cognitive biases can impact human-AI collaboration and highlight the need for tailored approaches to AI product design, rather than a single, universal solution.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。