arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2510.02153cs.HCcs.AI
收藏

决策中的人类-智能投顾协作:来自一项多阶段混合方法实验研究的证据

Human-Robo-advisor collaboration in decision-making: Evidence from a multiphase mixed methods experimental study

Rochester Institute of Technology(罗切斯特理工学院);Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode(印度管理学院科泽科德分校);LUT University(拉彭兰塔-拉赫蒂理工大学)

Hasan Mahmud, Najmul Islam, Satish Krishnan

AI总结:

本研究通过多阶段混合方法(含334人行为实验)探究人类与智能投顾(RA)的决策协作,发现RA性能信息、损益框架影响依赖程度,识别出3种RA角色、4类用户及2×2接受度前因类型学,为可信自适应RA设计提供依据。

摘要:

智能投顾(Robo-advisors, RAs)是人类理财顾问的高性价比、抗偏差替代方案,但其采用率仍然有限。尽管已有研究考察了用户与RA的交互,但人们对个体如何解读RA的角色、以及如何将其建议整合到决策中知之甚少。为填补这一空白,本研究采用多阶段混合方法设计,整合了一项行为实验(N=334)、主题分析和后续定量测试。研究结果表明,人们倾向于依赖RA,这种依赖程度受RA性能相关信息以及建议被框定为收益或损失的方式影响。主题分析揭示了决策中的三种RA角色和四类用户,每类都对应着不同的建议整合模式。此外,一项2×2的类型学将接受度的前因分为个体层面和算法层面的促成因素与阻碍因素。通过结合行为、阐释和验证性证据,本研究深化了对人类-RA协作的理解,并为设计更具可信度和适应性的RA系统提供了可行洞见。

英文摘要:

Robo-advisors (RAs) are cost-effective, bias-resistant alternatives to human financial advisors, yet adoption remains limited. While prior research has examined user interactions with RAs, less is known about how individuals interpret RA roles and integrate their advice into decision-making. To address this gap, this study employs a multiphase mixed methods design integrating a behavioral experiment (N = 334), thematic analysis, and follow-up quantitative testing. Findings suggest that people tend to rely on RAs, with reliance shaped by information about RA performance and the framing of advice as gains or losses. Thematic analysis reveals three RA roles in decision-making and four user types, each reflecting distinct patterns of advice integration. In addition, a 2 x 2 typology categorizes antecedents of acceptance into enablers and inhibitors at both the individual and algorithmic levels. By combining behavioral, interpretive, and confirmatory evidence, this study advances understanding of human-RA collaboration and provides actionable insights for designing more trustworthy and adaptive RA systems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑