arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2403.08115cs.CYcs.AIcs.CL
收藏

具有法律约束力但不公平?迈向评估隐私政策的公平性

Legally Binding but Unfair? Towards Assessing Fairness of Privacy Policies

Center for Scalable Data Analytics and Artificial Intelligence (ScaDS.AI)(可扩展数据分析与人工智能中心(ScaDS.AI))

Vincent Freiberger, Erik Buchmann

AI总结:

本文提出从信息公平性、表征公平性和伦理/道德三维度,结合文本统计、语言学方法与AI自动评估隐私政策,并通过德语政策实验验证其可行性。

摘要:

隐私政策被期望告知数据主体其数据保护权利,并应解释数据控制者的数据管理实践。隐私政策只有在被数据主体正确解读、理解和信任时,才能实现其目的。这意味着隐私政策须以公平的方式撰写,例如不使用两极分化的术语、不要求特定教育水平,也不预设某种特定社会背景。我们概述了评估隐私政策公平性的方法。我们从基础性法律来源和公平性研究中识别出信息公平性、表征公平性以及伦理/道德这些维度如何与隐私政策相关联。我们提出基于文本统计、语言学方法和人工智能,在这些公平性维度上自动评估政策的可选方案。我们使用德语隐私政策开展初步实验,以证明我们的方法具有适用性。实验表明,三个公平性维度均存在问题。这一点十分重要,因为未来的隐私政策可能会被用作法律人工智能模型的语料库。

英文摘要:

Privacy policies are expected to inform data subjects about their data protection rights and should explain the data controller's data management practices. Privacy policies only fulfill their purpose, if they are correctly interpreted, understood, and trusted by the data subject. This implies that a privacy policy is written in a fair way, e.g., it does not use polarizing terms, does not require a certain education, or does not assume a particular social background. We outline our approach to assessing fairness in privacy policies. We identify from fundamental legal sources and fairness research, how the dimensions informational fairness, representational fairness and ethics / morality are related to privacy policies. We propose options to automatically assess policies in these fairness dimensions, based on text statistics, linguistic methods and artificial intelligence. We conduct initial experiments with German privacy policies to provide evidence that our approach is applicable. Our experiments indicate that there are issues in all three dimensions of fairness. This is important, as future privacy policies may be used in a corpus for legal artificial intelligence models.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑