基于法律的公平目标
Legally grounded fairness objectives
摘要:
最近的工作已经确定了一些形式上不兼容的操作措施的不公平的机器学习(ML)系统。由于这些衡量标准都反映了公平制度的直观可取方面,因此不可能选择“唯一真实”的衡量标准,相反,合理的方法是尽量减少衡量标准的加权组合。然而,这只是提出了如何选择权重的问题。在这里,我们制定了基于法律的公平目标(LGFO),它使用来自法律系统的信号来非任意地衡量特定程度的不公平的社会成本。LGFO是推定诉讼下的预期损害赔偿,可能会判给那些被错误分类的人,从这个意义上说,ML系统做出的决定与法院首选措施下做出的决定不同。值得注意的是,计算LGFO所需的两个量,法院对公平措施的偏好,以及预期的损害赔偿,是未知的,但定义明确,可以通过法律咨询来估计。此外,由于法律制度规定的损害赔偿是为了衡量和补偿不公平分类对个人造成的伤害,《地方政府平等办公室法》与社会对社会成本的估计密切相关。
英文摘要:
Recent work has identified a number of formally incompatible operational measures for the unfairness of a machine learning (ML) system. As these measures all capture intuitively desirable aspects of a fair system, choosing "the one true" measure is not possible, and instead a reasonable approach is to minimize a weighted combination of measures. However, this simply raises the question of how to choose the weights. Here, we formulate Legally Grounded Fairness Objectives (LGFO), which uses signals from the legal system to non-arbitrarily measure the social cost of a specific degree of unfairness. The LGFO is the expected damages under a putative lawsuit that might be awarded to those who were wrongly classified, in the sense that the ML system made a decision different to that which would have be made under the court's preferred measure. Notably, the two quantities necessary to compute the LGFO, the court's preferences about fairness measures, and the expected damages, are unknown but well-defined, and can be estimated by legal advice. Further, as the damages awarded by the legal system are designed to measure and compensate for the harm caused to an individual by an unfair classification, the LGFO aligns closely with society's estimate of the social cost.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。