arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2403.01649cs.CYcs.AI
收藏

关于政府开发和使用先进自动化系统以作出涉及个人的决策的建议

Recommendations for Government Development and Use of Advanced Automated Systems to Make Decisions about Individuals

Susan Landau, James X. Dempsey, Ece Kamar, Steven M. Bellovin

AI总结:

本文围绕政府使用先进自动化系统作出涉个人决策时的可争议性,结合多方研讨会讨论提出政策与实践建议。

摘要:

可争议性——即有效质疑一项决策的能力——对于实现公平至关重要。在政府对个人作出决策的情境中,可争议性往往作为正当程序的一项要素而具有宪法层面的要求;与特定项目相关的州或联邦法律可能规定具体程序。此外,可争议性可以成为发现系统性错误的宝贵途径,有助于持续评估和系统改进。2024年1月24日至25日,在美国国家科学基金会和William and Flora Hewlett基金会的支持下,我们召集了一个多元群体举办研讨会,成员包括政府官员、领先科技公司代表、来自学术界和非营利部门的技术与政策专家、倡导者以及利益相关方,议题涉及先进自动化决策、可争议性和法律。基于研讨会丰富而广泛的讨论,我们提出这些建议。一份总结讨论内容的完整报告正在编写中。

英文摘要:

Contestability -- the ability to effectively challenge a decision -- is critical to the implementation of fairness. In the context of governmental decision making about individuals, contestability is often constitutionally required as an element of due process; specific procedures may be required by state or federal law relevant to a particular program. In addition, contestability can be a valuable way to discover systemic errors, contributing to ongoing assessments and system improvement. On January 24-25, 2024, with support from the National Science Foundation and the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, we convened a diverse group of government officials, representatives of leading technology companies, technology and policy experts from academia and the non-profit sector, advocates, and stakeholders for a workshop on advanced automated decision making, contestability, and the law. Informed by the workshop's rich and wide-ranging discussion, we offer these recommendations. A full report summarizing the discussion is in preparation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑