arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2406.10430cs.CYcs.AI
收藏

挑战机器:政府人工智能系统中的可争辩性

Challenging the Machine: Contestability in Government AI Systems

Susan Landau, James X. Dempsey, Ece Kamar, Steven M. Bellovin, Robert Pool

AI总结:

本文报告一场跨领域研讨会,围绕个人质疑政府AI决策的“可争辩性”要求,探讨先进自动化决策系统在开发、采购与使用中的挑战,并提出可执行建议。

摘要:

在2023年10月的一项行政命令(EO)中,拜登总统发布了一份详尽但在很大程度上具有愿景性质的路线图,旨在安全、负责任地开发和使用人工智能(AI)。2024年1月24日至25日研讨会面临的挑战,是把围绕一个具体而关键问题的这些愿景——即个人能够质疑政府针对其本人作出的决定——转化为可执行的指导,使各机构能够开发、采购并使用真正可争辩的先进自动化决策系统。尽管行政当局自2023年10月的行政命令以来已采取重要步骤,但我们从研讨会中获得的洞见仍具有高度现实意义,因为先进决策系统的可争辩性要求尚未得到充分界定或落实。\n\n该研讨会汇集了技术专家、政府机构和民间社会组织成员、诉讼律师以及研究人员,举行为期两天的密集会议,考察用户、开发者和机构在面向先进自动化决策系统实现可争辩性时所面临的挑战。为确保自由开放的讨论交流,会议依据修订版《查塔姆宫规则》举行。与会者可自由使用其了解到的任何信息或细节,但不得依据发言者身份或所属机构来归因会上发表的任何言论。因此,下文的研讨会总结对发言者及其所属机构作匿名处理。凡涉及对某一机构、公司或组织的指认,均来自公开且已标明来源的资料,并不一定反映研讨会与会者的发言。\n\n本文件是关于该研讨会的报告,并附有建议和说明性材料。

英文摘要:

In an October 2023 executive order (EO), President Biden issued a detailed but largely aspirational road map for the safe and responsible development and use of artificial intelligence (AI). The challenge for the January 24-25, 2024 workshop was to transform those aspirations regarding one specific but crucial issue -- the ability of individuals to challenge government decisions made about themselves -- into actionable guidance enabling agencies to develop, procure, and use genuinely contestable advanced automated decision-making systems. While the Administration has taken important steps since the October 2023 EO, the insights garnered from our workshop remain highly relevant, as the requirements for contestability of advanced decision-making systems are not yet fully defined or implemented. The workshop brought together technologists, members of government agencies and civil society organizations, litigators, and researchers in an intensive two-day meeting that examined the challenges that users, developers, and agencies faced in enabling contestability in light of advanced automated decision-making systems. To ensure a free and open flow of discussion, the meeting was held under a modified version of the Chatham House rule. Participants were free to use any information or details that they learned, but they may not attribute any remarks made at the meeting by the identity or the affiliation of the speaker. Thus, the workshop summary that follows anonymizes speakers and their affiliation. Where an identification of an agency, company, or organization is made, it is done from a public, identified resource and does not necessarily reflect statements made by participants at the workshop. This document is a report of that workshop, along with recommendations and explanatory material.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑