arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2403.00947q-bio.NCq-bio.QM
收藏

历史依赖性塑造脑—行为关系的因果推断

History-dependence shapes causal inference of brain-behaviour relationships

Brandon Caie, Gunnar Blohm

AI总结:

本文指出开放系统中历史依赖性的真实情况不可判定,会造成脑—行为数据的虚假相关,并从模型模拟与干预主义角度阐明其对神经科学因果推断的根本限制。

摘要:

行为与神经时间序列通常与过去相关。这种历史依赖性可能代表被测变量的一种基本属性,也可能源于混杂变量随时间变化的方式。本文认为,关于历史依赖性真实情况的不可判定性,是与环境交换信息的系统的一种普遍计算属性,并表明由此产生的不确定性会直接影响因果推断。我们首先论证,历史依赖性真实情况中的不确定性是开放系统的固有属性,无法被明确证伪。随后,我们模拟简单模型系统,以说明关于历史依赖性的不同假设如何导致虚假相关,以及数据分布中通常未被考虑的统计特性。接着,我们从干预主义视角考察这一问题,表明只有在干预过程与被测过程之间的潜在动态可先验获知,并且干预效应在所选择的分析层面上保持不变时,才能保证干预可纠正虚假相关问题。我们的结论是,关于历史依赖性的不确定性是神经系统研究的基本属性;鉴于此,我们讨论了神经科学中应如何评估因果性。

英文摘要:

Behavioural and neural time series are often correlated with the past. This history-dependence may represent a fundamental property of the measured variables, or may arise from how confounding variables change over time. Here we argue that undecidability about the ground-truth of history-dependence is a general computational property of systems that exchange information with its environment, and show that the resulting uncertainty has a direct impact on causal inference. We first argue that uncertainty in the ground truth of history-dependence is an inherent property of open systems that cannot be explicitly falsified. Simple model systems are then simulated to show how different assumptions about history-dependence can lead to spurious correlations and statistical properties of data distributions that are typically unaccounted for. We then consider this problem from an interventionist perspective, showing that interventions can only be guaranteed to remedy the spurious correlation problem when the latent dynamics between the intervention and measured processes are known a priori, and the effect of the intervention is invariant at the chosen level of analysis. We conclude that uncertainty about history-dependence is a fundamental property of the study of neural systems, and in light of this discuss how causality should be assessed in neuroscience.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑