arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2312.11274cs.HC
收藏

改善学生学习的混合人机辅导:一项三项研究准实验调查

Improving Student Learning with Hybrid Human-AI Tutoring: A Three-Study Quasi-Experimental Investigation

Danielle R. Thomas, Jionghao Lin, Erin Gatz, Ashish Gurung, Shivang Gupta, Kole Norberg, Stephen E. Fancsali, Vincent Aleven, Lee Branstetter, Emma Brunskill, Kenneth R. Koedinger

AI总结:

本研究通过三项准实验调查,验证了结合人类与AI辅导的模型在低收入中学中对学习成果的积极影响,尤其对低成就学生更有效,并展示了适应不同学校情境的准实验方法,为快速迭代创新提供指导。

摘要:

人工智能(AI)应用以支持人类辅导具有显著改善学习成果的潜力,但参与度问题依然存在,尤其是在低收入背景的学生中。我们引入了一种结合人类与AI辅导的AI辅助辅导模型,并假设这种协同作用将对学习过程产生积极影响。为验证这一假设,我们在三所城市和低收入中学进行了三项研究准实验:1)宾夕法尼亚州一所学校的125名学生;2)加利福尼亚州一所学校的385名学生(50%拉丁裔);3)宾夕法尼亚州一所特许学校的75名学生(100%黑人),所有学校均实施了类似的辅导模型。我们比较了参与人机辅导的学生与仅使用数学软件的学生学习分析数据。我们发现人机辅导具有积极效果,尤其是在学生的熟练度和使用情况方面,有证据表明成绩较低的学生可能比成绩较高的学生受益更多。我们展示了适应不同学校和数据可用性情境的准实验方法的使用,以实现快速数据驱动的迭代,从而将灵感创造引导为有效创新。未来工作侧重于改进辅导仪表板并优化辅导与学生比例,同时将每位学生的年度成本维持在约700美元。

英文摘要:

Artificial intelligence (AI) applications to support human tutoring have potential to significantly improve learning outcomes, but engagement issues persist, especially among students from low-income backgrounds. We introduce an AI-assisted tutoring model that combines human and AI tutoring and hypothesize that this synergy will have positive impacts on learning processes. To investigate this hypothesis, we conduct a three-study quasi-experiment across three urban and low-income middle schools: 1) 125 students in a Pennsylvania school; 2) 385 students (50% Latinx) in a California school; and 3) 75 students (100% Black) in a Pennsylvania charter school, all implementing analogous tutoring models. We compare learning analytics of students engaged in human-AI tutoring compared to students using math software only. We find human-AI tutoring has positive effects, particularly in student's proficiency and usage, with evidence suggesting lower achieving students may benefit more compared to higher achieving students. We illustrate the use of quasi-experimental methods adapted to the particulars of different schools and data-availability contexts so as to achieve the rapid data-driven iteration needed to guide an inspired creation into effective innovation. Future work focuses on improving the tutor dashboard and optimizing tutor-student ratios, while maintaining annual costs per students of approximately $700 annually.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑