智能导学系统是否惠及K-12学生?美国治疗效应异质性的元分析与评估
Do intelligent tutoring systems benefit K-12 students? A meta-analysis and evaluation of heterogeneity of treatment effects in the U.S
AI总结:
本文通过元分析评估智能导学系统对美国K-12学生学习成果的影响,发现其整体效应显著为正,并识别出已解例题、干预时长等关键调节变量,为优化ITS应用条件提供依据。
摘要:
为了扩大智能导学系统(ITS)在K-12学校中的使用,理解其使用在何种条件下最为有益至关重要。本元分析评估了ITS效应在美国小学、初中和高中研究中的异质性。该分析纳入了18项研究,涉及11个ITS,共77个效应量。总体而言,ITS对美国K-12学生学习成果具有显著的正向效应(g=0.271,SE=0.011,p=0.001)。此外,在小学和初中以及低成就学生中,效应量相似,但在包含农村学校的研究中效应量较低。MetaForest分析显示,提供已解例题、干预时长、干预条件、学习成果类型和即时测量是治疗效应最重要的调节变量。
英文摘要:
To expand the use of intelligent tutoring systems (ITS) in K-12 schools, it is essential to understand the conditions under which their use is most beneficial. This meta-analysis evaluated the heterogeneity of ITS effects across studies focusing on elementary, middle, and high schools in the U.S. It included 18 studies with 77 effect sizes across 11 ITS. Overall, there was a significant positive effect size of ITS on U.S. K-12 students' learning outcomes (g=0.271, SE=0.011, p=0.001). Furthermore, effect sizes were similar across elementary and middle schools, and for low-achieving students, but were lower in studies including rural schools. A MetaForest analysis showed that providing worked-out examples, intervention duration, intervention condition, type of learning outcome, and immediate measurement were the most important moderators of treatment effects.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。