arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2308.12955cs.CY
收藏

全球数据监管的新框架

A new framework for global data regulation

Ellie Graeden, David Rosado, Tess Stevens, Mallory Knodel, Rachele Hendricks-Sturrup, Andrew Reiskind, Ashley Bennett, John Leitner, Paul Lekas, Michelle DeMooy

AI总结:

针对当前数据监管中工具与结果分离导致的监管过度或不足问题,提出基于用例结果和关联权利的差异化监管框架,经开放银行等场景验证,可依托现有工程工具更有效保护广泛人权。

摘要:

在当前的数据保护监管框架下,广义人权的保护及相应结果的监管,在很大程度上独立于既威胁这些权利、又对保护这些权利必不可少的数据和工具。工具与其产生的结果之间的这种分离,在未与敏感用例关联时,存在对数据和工具本身监管过度的风险。与此同时,如果数据可以在限制较少的框架下被收集和处理,却被用于推动需要更高敏感度和更多限制的结果,这种分离也存在监管不足的风险。我们需要一种新的方法,以支持基于各行业内真正高风险用例的差异化保护。在此,我们提出一个监管框架,其适用对象并非特定数据或工具本身,而是与这些数据和工具在具体场景中的使用相关联的结果和权利。该框架旨在识别、应对并保护包括隐私在内的广泛人权,并提出一种更灵活的政策制定方法,与当前的工程工具和实践相契合。我们在开放银行(open banking)场景下测试了该框架,并阐述了当前的隐私增强技术(privacy-enhancing technologies)及其他工程策略如何应用于该场景以及接触者追踪应用(contract tracing applications)场景。这种数据保护监管方法更有效地依托现有工程工具,保护全球各地立法和宪法所定义的广泛人权。

英文摘要:

Under the current regulatory framework for data protections, the protection of human rights writ large and the corresponding outcomes are regulated largely independently from the data and tools that both threaten those rights and are needed to protect them. This separation between tools and the outcomes they generate risks overregulation of the data and tools themselves when not linked to sensitive use cases. In parallel, separation risks under-regulation if the data can be collected and processed under a less-restrictive framework, but used to drive an outcome that requires additional sensitivity and restrictions. A new approach is needed to support differential protections based on the genuinely high-risk use cases within each sector. Here, we propose a regulatory framework designed to apply not to specific data or tools themselves, but to the outcomes and rights that are linked to the use of these data and tools in context. This framework is designed to recognize, address, and protect a broad range of human rights, including privacy, and suggests a more flexible approach to policy making that is aligned with current engineering tools and practices. We test this framework in the context of open banking and describe how current privacy-enhancing technologies and other engineering strategies can be applied in this context and that of contract tracing applications. This approach for data protection regulations more effectively builds on existing engineering tools and protects the wide range of human rights defined by legislation and constitutions around the globe.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑