arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2308.04514cs.HC
收藏

支持协作式仪表盘设计的启发式方法

Heuristics for Supporting Cooperative Dashboard Design

Vidya Setlur, Michael Correll, Arvind Satyanarayan, Melanie Tory

AI总结:

本文将仪表盘设计重新界定为支持分析性对话的协作式体验,提出39条设计启发式规则,并通过52名研究生的实践验证其能揭示失败原因并促进更流畅、支持性更强的仪表盘设计。

摘要:

仪表盘已不再仅仅是静态的指标展示;通过交互和叙事等功能,它们已经发展为支持监控和报告等分析与沟通目标。然而,现有的仪表盘设计指南往往无法涵盖这种扩展后的范围,因为它们主要关注视觉设计的最佳实践。相比之下,我们将仪表盘设计界定为促进一场分析性对话:一种协作式、交互式的体验,用户可以在其中与底层数据进行交互、推理或自由查询。通过借鉴对话流程和沟通的既有原则,我们将协作式仪表盘定义为能够促成富有成效的分析性对话的仪表盘,并推导出一套包含39条仪表盘设计启发式规则,以支持有效的分析性对话。为了评估这一框架的实用性,我们请52名计算机科学与工程专业的研究生在一项不计分、自愿参加的课后作业中,运用我们的启发式规则来批评和设计仪表盘。参与者的反馈表明,我们的启发式规则揭示了仪表盘可能失败的新原因,并鼓励一种更流畅、更具支持性和响应性的仪表盘设计风格。我们的方法为未来工作提出了若干引人注目的方向,包括能够更好地预判对话轮次转换、修复和细化的仪表盘创作工具,以及将协作原则扩展到其他分析工作流程。

英文摘要:

Dashboards are no longer mere static displays of metrics; through functionality such as interaction and storytelling, they have evolved to support analytic and communicative goals like monitoring and reporting. Existing dashboard design guidelines, however, are often unable to account for this expanded scope as they largely focus on best practices for visual design. In contrast, we frame dashboard design as facilitating an analytical conversation: a cooperative, interactive experience where a user may interact with, reason about, or freely query the underlying data. By drawing on established principles of conversational flow and communication, we define the concept of a cooperative dashboard as one that enables a fruitful and productive analytical conversation, and derive a set of 39 dashboard design heuristics to support effective analytical conversations. To assess the utility of this framing, we asked 52 computer science and engineering graduate students to apply our heuristics to critique and design dashboards as part of an ungraded, opt-in homework assignment. Feedback from participants demonstrates that our heuristics surface new reasons dashboards may fail, and encourage a more fluid, supportive, and responsive style of dashboard design. Our approach suggests several compelling directions for future work, including dashboard authoring tools that better anticipate conversational turn-taking, repair, and refinement and extending cooperative principles to other analytical workflows.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑