arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2304.09732math.HOmath.LO
收藏

维特根斯坦论决策与数学实践

Wittgenstein on decisions and the mathematical practice

M. Muñoz Pérez

AI总结:

本文将克里普克怀疑论重新表述为对“如果-那么主义”与$V$-多元主义结合的挑战,并通过解读《哲学研究》提出解决方案,强调明确“决策”及其哲学价值是维护多元主义的关键。

摘要:

普特南与芬克尔斯坦可以被解读为通过诉诸数学通常被从事的方式来回应克里普克的怀疑论论证。如今,围绕多元主义的争论已经质疑了存在一种独特方式来开展数学活动这一假设。在本文中,我们希望将克里普克的论证重新表述为对“如果-那么主义”与一种合理的多元主义形式(我们称之为“$V$-多元主义”)之结合的挑战,同时提出对《哲学研究》若干段落的一种解读作为解决方案。我们的结论是,为了维护多元主义,我们需要澄清两个事实:我们确实做出了确定的“决策”,以及这些决策如我们所论证的那样具有哲学价值。探究这种价值的本质是本文希望涵盖的进一步任务之一。

英文摘要:

Putnam and Finkelstein can be read as providing an answer to Kripke's skeptical argument by appealing to the way mathematics is commonly pursued. Nowadays, the debate surrounding pluralism has questioned the postulation of a unique way of developing mathematical activity. In this paper, we wish to reformulate Kripke's argument as a challenge for the conjunction of 'ifthenism' and a reasonable form of pluralism (which we have called '$V$-pluralism') and, at the same time, propose a reading of some passages of the 'Philosophical Investigations' as a solution. Our conclusion is that, in order for pluralism to be preserved, we need to clarify both the fact that we make definite 'decisions' and the philosophical value that they, as we argue, bear. To investigate the nature of this value is one of the further tasks want to cover in this article.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑