现代定义与古代定义
Modern Definition and Ancient Definition
AI总结:
本文结合现代数学实践考察亚里士多德和波菲利的经典定义理论,旨在理解古今逻辑科学的鸿沟,并在 topos theory 视角下探讨古今定义实践相互诠释的可能性,发现古代定义实践提出了被现代文献忽视的问题。
摘要:
在这篇文章中,我们结合现代数学实践中执行定义的方式,考察了亚里士多德《Topics》和波菲利《Eisagogê》中编纂的经典定义理论的某些方面。我们的目标是有助于理解古代与现代逻辑和科学之间存在的所谓鸿沟,以及关于古代定义理论不充分和缺乏复杂性的指控背后的原因。同时,探讨现代数学定义实践与古代定义实践之间相互诠释的可能性,特别是在 topos theory 的视角下。我们发现古代定义实践提出了关于现代数学实践的相关且被忽视的问题,这些问题显然避开了当前的哲学和数理逻辑文献。我们还提出了一些关于理论的结构和发展的总体考量,因为它们与定义理论有关。
英文摘要:
In this essay we examine some aspects of the classical theory of definition as codified in Aristotle's \emph{Topics} and Porphyry's \emph{Eisagogê} in the light of the way definition is carried out in modern mathematical practice. Our goal is to contribute to the understanding of the alleged gap existing between ancient and modern logic and science as well as the reasons behind allegations of inadequacy and lack of sophistication in the ancient theory of definition. Also to investigate the possibility of a co-interpretation between modern mathematical definitional practice and ancient definitional practice in particular in the light of topos theory. We find the ancient definitional practice asks relevant and overlooked questions about modern mathematical practice which apparently have escaped current philosophical and mathematical logical literature. We also present some general considerations about the structure and development of theories as these relate to the theory of definition.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。