数学实践中的类比推理
Reasoning by Analogy in Mathematical Practice
摘要:
著名数学家的证词和实践表明,在数学中,表面类比和深层类比之间存在着重要的现象学和认识论差异。在本文中,我们提供了一个描述性的理论类比推理在数学中,说明一般条件下,一个类比可能提供真正的归纳支持的数学猜想(以上履行仅仅是启发性的作用,'建议'的心理意义上的猜想)。所提出的条件推广了Hesse(1963)在她关于经验科学中类比推理的有影响力的著作中提出的标准。通过几个案例研究,我们认为本文提出的解释在证明类比推理在数学中的使用方面比Bartha(2009)辩护的突出替代方案做得更好。此外,我们的建议提供了新的见解扩展到无限的情况下,已知在有限域中举行的数学性质的实践。
英文摘要:
The testimony and practice of notable mathematicians indicate that there is an important phenomenological and epistemological difference between superficial and deep analogies in mathematics. In this paper, we offer a descriptive theory of analogical reasoning in mathematics, stating general conditions under which an analogy may provide genuine inductive support to a mathematical conjecture (over and above fulfilling the merely heuristic role of 'suggesting' a conjecture in the psychological sense). The proposed conditions generalize the criteria put forward by Hesse (1963) in her influential work on analogical reasoning in the empirical sciences. By reference to several case-studies, we argue that the account proposed in this paper does a better job in vindicating the use of analogical inference in mathematics than the prominent alternative defended by Bartha (2009). Moreover, our proposal offers novel insights into the practice of extending to the infinite case mathematical properties known to hold in finite domains.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。